Difference between revisions of "Radiology Proposals 2012-2013"

From IHE Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(28 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
===Call for Proposals===
+
===Final Selection===
Interested parties are invited to submit proposal pages based on the '''[[Brief Proposal Template]]''' by 5 Oct 2012.
+
The workitems selected for the 2012-13 cycle were:
 +
:* [[Invoke Radiology Image Display Service - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]] (35%)
 +
:* [[Management of Radiology Report Templates - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]] (30%)
 +
:* [[Scheduled Workflow 2.0 - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]] (10%)
 +
:* [[White Paper - Mapping RadLex Codes into the IHE Radiology Scheduled Workflow Data Model - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]] (20%)
 +
:* [[Rad TF Maintenance 2012-13]] (15%)
 +
:* [[Stereotactic Breast Imaging - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]] (20%) - Below the Line
 +
 
 +
 
 +
The Planning Committee considered the following 2012-13 work items during the [[Rad Plan Minutes 2012-11-15|Nov 15 T-Con]] :
 +
 
 +
{| style="width:70%" border="1" cellpadding="4"
 +
! Proposals under Consideration                                                !! Editor      !! Effort !! Tag
 +
|-
 +
| [[Invoke Radiology Image Display Service - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]]  || D. Clunie    || 35%    || A
 +
|-
 +
| [[Management of Radiology Report Templates - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]] || C. Langlotz  || 30%    || B
 +
|-
 +
| [[Reporting Workflow Revision - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]]              || K. O'Donnell || 35%    || C
 +
|-
 +
| [[White Paper - Mapping RadLex Codes into the IHE Radiology Scheduled Workflow Data Model - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]] || T. Sippel    || 20%    || D
 +
|-
 +
| [[Scheduled Workflow 2.0 - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]]                  || M. Suzuki    || 10%    || E1
 +
|-
 +
|  ---including ORM replacement                                                ||              || 45%    || E2
 +
|-
 +
| [[Radiology Imaging Report Content Profile - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]] || K. Ho        || 25%    || F1
 +
|-
 +
|  ---including paralleling/mapping SINR & XD*                                ||              || 40%    || F2
 +
|-
 +
| [[Retrieve preformatted images over web services - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]] || C. Lindop    || 30%    || G
 +
|-
 +
| [[Stereotactic Breast Imaging - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]]             || J. Keyes    || 20%    || H
 +
|-
 +
| [[Rad TF Maintenance 2012-13]]                                              || CoChairs    || 15%    || I
 +
|}
 +
 
 +
 
 +
The committee chose to use the same ranking as last year (individual profile ranking and if the total slightly exceeds 100%, the final ranked workitem is "below the line", meaning if the Tech Cmte finds itself without enough bandwidth to complete the work, the "below the line" workitem is the first candidate to sacrifice).  The Maintenance proposal must always be selected.
  
You are also welcome to update and resubmit proposals from '''[[Radiology Proposals 2011-2012|last year]]''' or earlier.
+
A ballot was prepared at www.modernballots.com.  The system uses the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schulze_method Schulze Method] of Condorcet voting to determine winners by examining each candidate pairwise against each other candidate in terms of how many voters preferred A over B and how many preferred B over A and optimizing to satisfy the most preferences.
  
 +
The detailed results are [https://modernballots.com/elections/sgir6qw8/view/ available online].  (Committee note: next year set up the ballot ahead on time on modernballots so everyone can enter their ballots directly rather then spending effort on re-entering).
  
1. Enter the name of your proposal (e.g. Management of Radiology Report Templates - Brief Proposal) and click the Create button.
+
===Detailed Proposals===
 +
Detailed proposals were due Oct 26. The proposals were reviewed by the Technical Committee on [[Rad_Tech_Minutes_2012-11-01|Nov 1]]:
  
<createbox>
+
Tech Cmte evaluations are recorded at the bottom of each detailed proposal.
type=create
 
buttonlabel=Create New Proposal
 
preload=Brief Proposal Template
 
editintro=Brief Proposal Instructions
 
align=left
 
width=45
 
break=no
 
</createbox>
 
  
2. Finishing editing your new page, then edit '''this''' page (see the edit button up at the top) to add a link to your new page to the list below.
+
Note: The Letter Codes below here are those used for short list selection. The Final selection above resets the numbering to ABC
  
Proposals may also be submitted by completing the  [ftp://iheyr2@ftp.ihe.net/Document_templates/IHE%20Profile%20Proposal%20Template-Brief.doc MS-Word version of the template] and emailing the completed document to [mailto:radiology@ihe.net radiology@ihe.net].
+
:* 83 H. [[Invoke Radiology Image Display Service - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]]
 +
:* 77 M. [[Management of Radiology Report Templates - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]]
 +
:* 74 F. [[Reporting Workflow Revision - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]]
 +
:* 71 C. [[White Paper - Mapping RadLex Codes into the IHE Radiology Scheduled Workflow Data Model - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]]
 +
:* 70 D. [[Scheduled Workflow 2.0 - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]]
 +
:* 61 B. [[Radiology Imaging Report Content Profile - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]]
 +
:* 59 G. [[Retrieve preformatted images over web services - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]]
 +
:* 59 J. [[Stereotactic Breast Imaging - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013]]
 +
:* -- A. [[Rad TF Maintenance 2012-13]]
  
 
===Brief Proposals===
 
===Brief Proposals===
:* [[Rad TF Maintenance 2012-13]]
 
  
:* [[Radiology Imaging Report Content Profile - Brief Proposal]]
+
:* A. [[Rad TF Maintenance 2012-13]]
:* [[White Paper- Mapping RadLex Codes into the IHE Radiology Scheduled Workflow Data Model]]
 
:* [[Scheduled Workflow 2.0 - Brief Proposal]]
 
  
===See Also===
+
Selected for Review by Technical Committee (top 8, listed in descending priority):
* [http://www.acr.org/SecondaryMainMenuCategories/GR_Econ/FeaturedCategories/federal/hhs/ACRCommentstotheHHSHITPolicyCommitteeMeaningfulUsePart2.aspx ACR Meaningful Use Proposal] - a categorized list of meaningful HIT use cases in Radiology
+
 
 +
:* 83 H. [[Invoke Radiology Image Display Service - Brief Proposal]]
 +
:* 77 M. [[Management of Radiology Report Templates - Brief Proposal]]
 +
:* 74 F. [[Reporting Workflow Revision - Brief Proposal]]
 +
:* 71 C. [[White Paper- Mapping RadLex Codes into the IHE Radiology Scheduled Workflow Data Model]]
 +
:* 70 D. [[Scheduled Workflow 2.0 - Brief Proposal]]
 +
:* 61 B. [[Radiology Imaging Report Content Profile - Brief Proposal]]
 +
:* 59 G. [[Retrieve preformatted images over web services - Brief Proposal]]
 +
:* 59 J. [[Stereotactic Breast Imaging - Brief Proposal]]
 +
 
 +
Rejected (in descending priority):
 +
 
 +
:* 53 E. [[Imaging Appropriateness Criteria - Brief Proposal]]
 +
:* 48 I. [[Radiology Data Migration - Brief Proposal]]
 +
:* 39 L. [[Life Cycle Management - Brief Proposal]]
 +
:* 35 K. [[Long Term Archiving - Brief Proposal]]
 +
 
 +
===Call for Proposals===
 +
Interested parties were invited to submit proposal pages based on the '''[[Brief Proposal Template]]''' by Oct. 5, 2012.
  
 +
Last years proposals and process are here: '''[[Radiology Proposals 2011-2012]]'''.
  
 +
===Committee Links===
 
[[Radiology Planning Committee]]
 
[[Radiology Planning Committee]]
  
 
[[Radiology Technical Committee]]
 
[[Radiology Technical Committee]]

Latest revision as of 18:09, 26 November 2012

Final Selection

The workitems selected for the 2012-13 cycle were:


The Planning Committee considered the following 2012-13 work items during the Nov 15 T-Con :

Proposals under Consideration Editor Effort Tag
Invoke Radiology Image Display Service - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013 D. Clunie 35% A
Management of Radiology Report Templates - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013 C. Langlotz 30% B
Reporting Workflow Revision - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013 K. O'Donnell 35% C
White Paper - Mapping RadLex Codes into the IHE Radiology Scheduled Workflow Data Model - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013 T. Sippel 20% D
Scheduled Workflow 2.0 - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013 M. Suzuki 10% E1
---including ORM replacement 45% E2
Radiology Imaging Report Content Profile - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013 K. Ho 25% F1
---including paralleling/mapping SINR & XD* 40% F2
Retrieve preformatted images over web services - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013 C. Lindop 30% G
Stereotactic Breast Imaging - Detailed Proposal - 2012-2013 J. Keyes 20% H
Rad TF Maintenance 2012-13 CoChairs 15% I


The committee chose to use the same ranking as last year (individual profile ranking and if the total slightly exceeds 100%, the final ranked workitem is "below the line", meaning if the Tech Cmte finds itself without enough bandwidth to complete the work, the "below the line" workitem is the first candidate to sacrifice). The Maintenance proposal must always be selected.

A ballot was prepared at www.modernballots.com. The system uses the Schulze Method of Condorcet voting to determine winners by examining each candidate pairwise against each other candidate in terms of how many voters preferred A over B and how many preferred B over A and optimizing to satisfy the most preferences.

The detailed results are available online. (Committee note: next year set up the ballot ahead on time on modernballots so everyone can enter their ballots directly rather then spending effort on re-entering).

Detailed Proposals

Detailed proposals were due Oct 26. The proposals were reviewed by the Technical Committee on Nov 1:

Tech Cmte evaluations are recorded at the bottom of each detailed proposal.

Note: The Letter Codes below here are those used for short list selection. The Final selection above resets the numbering to ABC

Brief Proposals

Selected for Review by Technical Committee (top 8, listed in descending priority):

Rejected (in descending priority):

Call for Proposals

Interested parties were invited to submit proposal pages based on the Brief Proposal Template by Oct. 5, 2012.

Last years proposals and process are here: Radiology Proposals 2011-2012.

Committee Links

Radiology Planning Committee

Radiology Technical Committee