Difference between revisions of "ITI Change Proposals 2012"
Line 409: | Line 409: | ||
| No PID segment in PDQ response if PID-3 empty | | No PID segment in PDQ response if PID-3 empty | ||
| 2a | | 2a | ||
− | | | + | | Proposed -02 version to resolve comments. Confirm with Gerry and Elliot. |
|- | |- | ||
| [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Ballots/Ballot-16/CP-ITI-538-01.doc 538] | | [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Ballots/Ballot-16/CP-ITI-538-01.doc 538] |
Revision as of 10:24, 7 December 2012
Introduction
The ITI CP process follows the general IHE CP process described on the Change Proposal process page. The following sections give more detail on the general process for ITI participants involved in the CP process.
The ITI specific CP Process
The following text explains what the process used by the ITI commitee in processing submitted CPs. It is consistent with the general IHE CP process and is informative only.
- Submission into the Incoming directory. This is typically done via an email to the ITI Technical Committee co-chairs in charge of CPs (currently Rob Horn and Derrick Evans) and directly updating the directory if you have access.
- First consideration by the committee. If CP is accepted it is given a CP #, assigned an editor, renamed to CP-ITI-xxx-00.doc and placed in Assigned. If CP is rejected it is moved to Rejected and submitter is informed of explanation for rejection. Likely reasons for rejection are: duplicate, merged, withdrawn or not enough information to understand the request. Rejected CPs can be resubmitted with more information for reconsideration.
- Committee works with editor to draft the CP. Versions are kept in Assigned directory and numbered -00, -01, -02, etc.
- Committee decides CP is ready for ballot. Latest version of CP is moved to Completed diretory and old versions are moved to old_versions.
- Co-chair collects Completed CPs into a ballot. The Ballot directory will be used for this.
- Ballot is released to the general community for voting
- Votes and comments are collected. All yes votes means the CP passed ballot and moved to FinalText. No votes are resolved by the committee. Sometimes CP is withdrawn, sometimes NO voter changes to yes vote after explanations. CP may be updated in this process. If updates are insignificant (clarification only) the CP is considered passed. If updates are significant the CP is submitted for another ballot.
- CP approved in ballot are put in FinalText and scheduled to be integrated into the Technical Framework or Supplement.
Directory Structure
As CPs are processed through various statuses they move from one directory to another. The directories invoved are:
- Assigned
- contains CPs that have been assigned an editor and are being actively worked on by the committee, i.e. Assigned status
- Ballots
- contains Ballots that have been released for voting by the general community
- Canceled
- contains CPs that have been canceled, i.e. Canceled status
- Completed
- contains the last version of a CP that is in Completed status. It is waiting to be put in a ballot
- FinalText
- contains the last version of a CP that is in FinalText status. It is has been approved by ballot and is waiting to be integrated into the TF.
- FinalText/Integrated
- contains the version of the CP that was integrated into the TF.
- Incoming
- contains CPs which have been submitted but have not been assigned a CP number or an editor. This is the place that new incoming CPs are placed prior to the first stage of processing by the committee.
- old_versions
- Contains old versions of Completed and FinalText CPs
- Rejected
- CPs that have been submitted by rejected by the committee
- Status
- contains spreadsheets describing the status of CPs.
Archived Change Proposal pages
Ongoing work on CPs is placed on the current year CP page. Prior years work can be accessed at:
- ITI Change Proposals 2011
- ITI Change Proposals 2010
- ITI Change Proposals 2009
- ITI Change Proposals 2008
- ITI Change Proposals 2007
ITI CP Tracking
All Change Propoposal management is in ITI CP ftp site. The tracking spreadsheet can be accessed at Status directory. It is the file with the most recent date in that directory.
Integrated CPs 2012
These CPs have been integrated into the Version 9.0 of the Technical Framework and the 2012 version of Supplements.
CP | Title | Profile or Volumes Affected |
---|---|---|
414 | IHE ITI TF Vol 2: Appendix L | 2 |
504 | XDR Actors support Async Option | 2b |
516 | Correct hyperlinks to point to TF sections | XUA |
524 | XDS Metadata author and intended recipient extension | 3 |
527 | Remove *CodeDisplayName Registry enforcement | 3 |
536 | Datatype Typos | 2b |
550 | Additional XDR errorCode values | 2 |
573 | Remove XForms Option | RFD |
587 | Remove specialization of UserIsRequestor | 2 |
589 | ATNA Encrypttion Reference in XDS Vol1 Security Considerations | 1 |
600 | Change table 4.1.9 Folder metadata for including “Deprecated availabilityStatus” | 3 |
602 | XUA Extension Subject:role version | XUA |
603 | Update expected Actions when Document Recipient receives metadata error | 2b |
604 | Correct outdated reference to Audit Trail message payload schema | 2 |
605 | Error message on size mismatch | 3 |
606 | XUA++ Authz-Consent Option | XUA |
607 | Extension On Media Encryption | 2b |
608 | Zip over Email | 2b |
609 | Zip over Email Response | 2b |
612 | DSUB Specific Query UUID | DSUB |
616 | HPD Query and Feed operations use same parameter type | HPD |
618 | XUA++ Authz-Consent Option - XACML Solution | XUA |
619 | XCPD WSDL elements not adequately defined | XCPD |
626 | Typos in table 4.1-8 Document Metadata Attribute Enforcement | 3 |
627 | Author metadata attribute should not allow author with only a role or specialty | 3 |
628 | authorTelecommunication attribute should be multi-valued | 3 |
631 | XDSExtraMetadataNotSaved code inconsistent | 3 |
636 | XDS-SD Support for Character Set Encoding for plain text | 3 |
637 | Address XDW Inconsistencies" | XDW |
640 | Clarify option requirements in XDW | XDW |
641 | Define Code for Workflow Status in eventCodeList | XDW |
642 | Define Code for Workflow Status in eventCodeList | XDW |
644 | Retire DRR | Vol 1, 2b |
Note CP-644 was integrated without a ballot as part of the Profile retirement process.
Integrated CPs 2011
These CPs have been integrated into the Version 8.0 of the Technical Framework and the 2011 version of Supplements.
CP | Title | Profiles Affected |
---|---|---|
368 | SMTP clarifications for XDS.a and XDM | ATNA |
376 | extend PIXV3/PDQV3 R-MIM | PIX/PDQ |
454 | Patient Name in V3 PIX Get Corresponding Query Should Match V2 | PIXV3 |
455 | PIX/PDQ V3 - ControlActProcess moodCode should be EVN | PIX/PDQV3 |
459 | Retrieve example is wrong | XDS |
460 | SourcePatientId example wrong | XDS |
474 | The PIX/PDQv3 supplement does not document Audit Record Rqmts in Security Considerations | PIX/PDQv3 |
479 | Improve error reporting for XDS,XCA,XDR | "XCA,XDS,XDR" |
481 | Section references in table without a table title are incorrect | PWP |
485 | RFD urn values are defined incorrectly based on V.3.2.1.1 IHE-WSP201 | RFD |
494 | Permit Secure App in XCA | XCA |
505 | Improve examples | PIX/PDQV3 |
506 | Profile Use Of Coding Systems | PIX/PDQV3 |
509 | XDS Stored Query which associations to return | XDS.b |
510 | soapAction deprecation | Appendix V |
512 | XDSDocumentSet.intendedRecipient | XD* |
518 | XCPD comments | XCPD |
521 | ExternalIdentifier Clarification | X* |
531 | XCA specify passthru of query request/response content | XCA |
534 | Wrong wrappers for ITI-55 | XCPD |
535 | XCPD: one and only one actOrderRequired element | XCOD |
539 | Allow wildcards in PDQv3 | PDQ |
542 | Introduction section is missing for PDQ v3 | PDQ |
544 | Correct type for On-Demand Document Entries object type | XDS |
546 | Delete reference to ITI-16 | XDS |
547 | On-Demand Document Source replaces persisted documents | XDS |
548 | Document Registry or Document Recipient audit message | XDS |
549 | HPD Duplicate OID | HPD |
555 | BPPC code | BPPC |
556 | HPD Corrections | HPD |
557 | Wrong wrappers for ITI-55 | XCPD |
558 | Case of arguments in XCA Retrieve examples not correct | XCA |
561 | XUA++ PurposeOfUse example lists wrong child element | XUA |
563 | Specify use of IHE Profile in MSH-21 | all |
564 | Clarify IHE Profiling of Field Delimiters | all |
565 | HPD - Attribute Name Wrong | HPD |
566 | HPD - typos in attribute names | HPD |
567 | XCA FindDocuments specifiation of homeCommunityId | XCA |
568 | Typo in ISO standard number | HPD |
569 | Both HTTP-POSTand SOAP allowed for Archive Form | RFD |
571 | Use of CDATA in XDS-SD Content | XDS-SD |
572 | Typo in XCPD example of homeCommunityId | XCPD |
574 | Correct Optionality Typo | HPD |
577 | Is SourcePatientID single or multi-valued | XDS |
578 | XCA needs to more clearly call out the need for patient ID translation | XDS |
583 | Fix incorrect reference | XCA |
585 | Leading Zero in Transaction ID | ITI-30, ITI-31 |
591 | Error in 3rd component in PDQ Query Response | PDQ |
592 | Fix section labelling in DSUB | DSUB |
593 | Editorial change of CDA R1 into CDA R2 | XDS |
597 | ATNA Reference in XUA | XUA |
Ballots
Ballot 16 (ballot issued)
CP | Title | Profile or Volumes Affected | Ballot Result |
---|---|---|---|
537 | No PID segment in PDQ response if PID-3 empty | 2a | Proposed -02 version to resolve comments. Confirm with Gerry and Elliot. |
538 | Handle CX datatype as undividable in PDQ query. | 2a | One negative vote, Comments to be resolved |
540 | PIX Query, repeated ERR segment for Case 5 | 2a | Comments to be resolved |
601 | Extend HPD memberOf to support attributes on relationship | HPD | approved, no comments(affirmative 10, abstain 3) |
610 | DSUB correction for event ID in audit message | DSUB | approved, no comments(affirmative 10, abstain 3) |
611 | DSUB Correct Query Parameter Encoding | DSUB | approved, no comments(affirmative 10, abstain 3) |
632 | Metadata for stable versions of on-demand documents | XD* | approved, no comments(affirmative 10, abstain 3) |
645 | Folder | DSUB | approved, no comments(affirmative 10, abstain 3) |
646 | Author Encoding in XDW too limited | XDW | approved, no comments(affirmative 10, abstain 3) |
647 | DSUB contains reference to PCC APR profile that no longer exists | DSUB | approved, no comments(affirmative 10, abstain 3) |
Ballot 15
CP | Title | Profile or Volumes Affected |
---|---|---|
516 | Correct hyperlinks to point to TF sections | XUA |
527 | Remove *CodeDisplayName Registry enforcement | 3 |
606 | XUA++ Authz-Consent Option | XUA |
637 | Address XDW Inconsistencies" | XDW |
640 | Clarify option requirements in XDW | XDW |
641 | Define Code for Workflow Status in eventCodeList | XDW |
642 | Define Code for Workflow Status in eventCodeList | XDW |
Ballot 14
CP | Title | Profiles or Volumes Affected |
---|---|---|
414 | IHE ITI TF Vol 2: Appendix L | 2 |
504 | XDR Actors support Async Option | 2b |
516 | Correct hyperlinks to point to TF sections | 2 |
527 | Remove *CodeDisplayName Registry enforcement | 2a |
550 | Additional XDR errorCode values | 2 |
587 | Remove specialization of UserIsRequestor | 2 |
589 | ATNA Encrypttion Reference in XDS Vol1 Security Considerations | 1 |
606 | XUA++ Authz-Consent Option | XUA |
616 | HPD Query and Feed operations use same parameter type | HPD |
618 | XUA++ Authz-Consent Option - XACML Solution | XUA |
626 | Typos in table 4.1-8 Document Metadata Attribute Enforcement | 3 |
627 | Author metadata attribute should not allow author with only a role or specialty | 3 |
628 | authorTelecommunication attribute should be multi-valued | 3 |
631 | XDSExtraMetadataNotSaved code inconsistent | 3 |
636 | XDS-SD Support for Character Set Encoding for plain text | 3 |
Ballot 13 (CPs that passed)
See 2011 directory on ftp site
CP | Title | Profiles or Volumes Affected |
---|---|---|
524 | XDS Metadata author and intended recipient extension | 3 |
536 | Datatype Typos | 2b |
573 | Remove XForms Option | RFD |
600 | Change table 4.1.9 Folder metadata for including “Deprecated availabilityStatus” | 3 |
602 | XUA Extension Subject:role version | XUA |
603 | Update expected Actions when Document Recipient receives metadata error | 2b |
604 | Correct outdated reference to Audit Trail message payload schema | 2 |
605 | Error message on size mismatch | 3 |
607 | Extension On Media Encryption | 2b |
608 | Zip over Email | 2b |
609 | Zip over Email Response | 2b |
612 | DSUB Specific Query UUID | DSUB |
619 | XCPD WSDL elements not adequately defined | XCPD |
Assigned CPs
CP assignment
For a list of CPs as they are currently assigned see the latest CP-ITI-Tracking-2012-nn-nn.xls file in the Status directory.
Agenda and Minutes from CP discussions
7 December, 9-11 Central
Agenda
- Discuss CPs
- CP-650 OASIS/ebXML Registry Information Model constraint
- Alternatives Discussion
- CP-659 XD* MetaData Specialization to Include Accession/Order/Request Number
- Brief Discussion, but Moehrke and several other key players cannot make the call, so just gathering of comments.
- CP-536 Datatype Typos
- CP-537 No PID seqment in PDQ response
- CP-538 Handle CX datatype as undividable in PDQ query
- CP-540 PIX Query, repeated ERR segment
- CP-541 Update requirements for PIX Manager COnfiguration
- CP-655 Fix logic for patient death in PAM
- CP-650 OASIS/ebXML Registry Information Model constraint
- Incoming CP Discussions
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-X08_IHE-D_03.docx
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-KW-XCPD-schema-conflict.doc
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-LF-ClarifyUpdateExpectedActions.doc
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-Forcare-MHD-IncorrectUseOf403StatusCode.doc
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-Forcare-MHD-ClarificationOfJsonEncoding.doc
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-Forcare-MHD-ClarificationOfJsonDocumentDossierUrls.doc
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-Forcare-XDW-UniqueIdEncoding.doc
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-Forcare-XDW-InputOutputDefinition.doc
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-RAD_XDS-I_Metadata_AcccessionNumber.doc
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-TPA-more-restrictive-authorTelecommmunications.doc
- Ballot-16 Results
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Ballots/Ballot-16/Combined-Ballot-16.xls Combined ballot results
- Substantive comments on
- ITI-537 No PID segment in PDQ response if PID-3 empty (One negative vote)
- ITI-538 Handle CS datatype as undividable in PDQ query (One negative vote)
- ITI-540 PIX Query, repeated ERR segment for Case 5
- All other CPs approved 10 affirmative, 3 abstentions, with no comments
Minutes
26 October, 9-11 Central
1000h Central
Agenda
- Discuss CPs
- None ready
- Incoming CP Discussions
- ftp://iheyr2@ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-X01_IHE-D_01.docx
- ftp://iheyr2@ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-X02_IHE-D_01.docx
- ftp://iheyr2@ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-X03_IHE-D_01.docx
- ftp://iheyr2@ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-X08_IHE-D_02.docx
- ftp://iheyr2@ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-arsenal-ExendFilterExpressions.doc
- Ballot-16 Reminder
(Due by EOB today)
Minutes
- CP Review
- Re-assign CP-650 to Sylvie.
- Ballot 16 list
- Ballot 16 will issue next week.
- Incoming
- CP-654-00 CP-ITI-X01_IHE-D_01.docx
Needs additional editorial work Needs rationale explanation of why this does not break compliant existing implementations, or, if it does, make this a named option.
- CP-655-00 Modify field predicate logic for conditional fields PID-29, PID-30 (Patient Death) of IHE PAM
- CP-656-00 Reliable Patient Identity (PID-32) in IHE PAM
- CP-657-00 Presentation next tcon on alternatives and rationale.
- CP-658-00 Subscribe Submission metadata
- CP-659-00 Radiology CP to be provided to extend eventcodelist.
- Assigned
- No discussions
September 21, 2012
1000h Central
Agenda
- Discuss CPs
- Confirm 537, 538, 540 Complete
- Review 610
- Review 611
- Review 645
- Review 646
- Review 601
- Incoming CP Discussions
- none
Minutes
- CP Review
- CP-537 reviewed and ready for ballot
- CP-538 reviewed and ready for ballot
- CP-540 reviewed and ready for ballot
- CP-610 reviewed and ready for ballot
- CP-611 reviewed and ready for ballot
- CP-645 reviewed and ready for ballot
- CP-646 reviewed and ready for ballot. The added elements are worth the invalidation of existing workflow documents. This is trial implementation feedback.
- CP-612 needs focused discussion needed between mark, john, rob before the next CP tcon. Mark sending email with suggested times.
- CP-653 of spreadsheet was duplicate of 646. CP-653 not assigned
- CP-601 reviewed and ready for ballot.
- Ballot 16 list
- CP-632-01
- CP-601-04
- CP-537-01
- CP-538-01
- CP-540-01
- CP-610-00
- CP-611-01
- CP-645-03
- CP-646-00
- CP-647-01
- Ballot 16 will issue next week.
- Incoming
- CP-ITI-HPD-Errors.doc assigned CP-653. This needs an editor. Co-chair temporarily named editor to find a knowledgeable editor.
- CP-ITI-PullStyleNotification too complex to make a CP. Make this a profile proposal.
September 7, 2012
1000h Central
Agenda
- Discuss CPs
- DSUB and Pull style notifications
- XDW/XBeR and homeCommunityId
- CP-645
- CP-647
- Incoming CP Discussions
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-TF_clarify_ebRIM_referenced_document.doc assigned CP-650
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-arsenal-ExendFilterExpressions.doc - assigned-651
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-SC_TF_XDSDSG_SUPPL_SIGN_METH.doc assigned CP-652
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-Forcare-XDW-AuthorEncoding.doc assigned CP-653
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-Forcare-DSUB-MinimalNotificationShouldEnableUniqueIdentificationOfXdsMetadataSets.doc asssigned CP-649
Minutes
- CP-645 double assigned to Mark Sinke. Revision
- CP-645 given to Folder
- CP-649 given to Minimal Notification
- CP-650 OASIS registry model, probably maintain minimal ebRIM. Do CP so clarified before ReDoc is published.
- CP-651 Subscribe Submission metadata. Needs serious discussion with people not on tcon. Significant extension to DSUB.
- CP-652 Relax restrictions on hashing. Full relax will cause interop problems, but we may need to reword to deal with future issues. E.g., retirement of SHA-1.
- Missing people on tcon, move to next tcon
- DSUB and Pull style notifications
- XDW/XBeR and homeCommunityId
- CP-645 Discussed. Likely result is editorial changes that clarify the language without changing any "shall" requirements.
- CP-647 Reviewed, Complete and ready for next ballot.
August 24, 2012
1000h Central
Agenda
- Discuss CPs
- CP-614-01
- CP-601-02
- DSUB and Pull style notifications
- XDW/XBeR and homeCommunityId
- Incoming CP Discussions
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-SC_TF_XDSDSG_SUPPL_SIGN_METH.doc
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-LF-BadReftoPCCsAPRprofile.doc
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-Forcare-XDW-AuthorEncoding.doc
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-Forcare-DSUB-MinimalNotificationShouldEnableUniqueIdentificationOfXdsMetadataSets.doc
Minutes
- CP 614 Discussed
- Incoming
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-SC_TF_XDSDSG_SUPPL_SIGN_METH.doc assigned CP 648
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-LF-BadReftoPCCsAPRprofile.doc assigned CP 647
- ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-Forcare-XDW-AuthorEncoding.doc assigned CP 646
- ftp://iheyr2@ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-Forcare-DSUB-MinimalNotificationShouldEnableUniqueIdentificationOfXdsMetadataSets.doc assigned CP 645
- Next Ballot issued out of 21 September tcon
- Discuss 601 21 September
- Next tcon 7 Sept,
- DSUB and Pull style notifications
- XDW/XBeR and homeCommunityId
- More Incoming
- Any priority CPs (Nag) needed for connectathon
July 17, 2012
1330h Central
Agenda
- Incoming CP Discussions
- ftp://iheyr2@ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-DSUB-makeDSUBmorePowerful.doc
- ftp://iheyr2@ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-Use-of-urn_ihe.doc
- ftp://iheyr2@ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-X01_IHE-D_01.docx
- ftp://iheyr2@ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-X02_IHE-D_01.docx
- ftp://iheyr2@ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-X03_IHE-D_01.docx
- ftp://iheyr2@ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-LF-ClarificationOfHashSize.doc
- Discuss CPs
- CP-614 Walco to prepare initial Security discussions. Discuss again during F2F.
Minutes
- Discussion
- CP-523 changes were integrated and it should be made FT
- One CP-523 change will be part of CP-649
- CP Tcon, 24 August 9-11 Central
- CP Tcon, 21 September 9-11 Central
- Ballot #16 Issue: 26 September, Last Chance for Connectathon Changes
- Ballot #16: Comments/Votes due 24 October
- CP Tcon, 26 October, 9-11 Central review comments
- CP Tcon, 7 December, 9-11 Central
- Incoming
July 7, 2012
1000h Central
Agenda
- Discuss Ballot #15 comments
- Discuss CPs
- CP-601
- CP-611-00 ready for ballot?
- CP-614-00 ready for ballot?
- CP-615
- CP-630
- CP-644 ready for FT?
- Incoming CP Discussions
Minutes
- Ballot 15 comment resolution
- CP-637 (Negatives -> Abstain) (Spreadsheet had 638 with 622's name). Affirmative votes verified to have been for 637.
- CP-640 Rename the option. (Lynn to finish name changes)
- John Donnelly to submit companion related CP to PCC about View option.
- CP-641 Needs update to table of codes
- All approved, given edits described above.
- Discussion
- CP-601 HPD-02 basically agreed, various minor edits needed.
- CP-611 needs some editorial work for editor instruction format.
- CP-614 discussed. Walco to prepare initial Security discussions. Discuss again during F2F.
- CP-644 approved. This does not need ballot because it is only the editorial changes needed to implement the prior decision to retire DRR in favor of XDW. It is ready for Final Text.
- Incoming
June 8, 2012
1000h Central
Agenda
- Incoming CP Discussions
- Discuss CPs
- Ballot-15 reminder: The spreadsheet and email list were updated to correct a typo. First version listed CP-637 as "Update DICOM to FT". Corrected version got the title fix, to "Address XDW Inconsistencies". The ballot zip file did contain 637-00 and should have had 637-01. The minutes listed 637.
- ITI-CP-606 ballot comments (Massimiliano Masi)
Minutes
- Incoming
- RFD-editorial-corrections to be CP-644
- XDW-folder to be CP-645
- HPD-errors to be reviewed next meeting
- Ballot 15 message
- Extend due date to 15 June.
- Note 637-01, not 637-00. Attach 637-02. Update ftp site, new zip file.
- Ballot 16 message
- Call for CP's to be ready for discussion on 6 July tcon
- Find and re-assign the orphaned CPs.
- Finalized during F2F meeting
- Reminder to all editors/contributors (provide list)
- Discussion
- Clarify editors instructions for CP-ITI-606. Masimiliano to prepare version with revised editors comments (strikeout of old text, new instructions, etc.)
- CP-ITI-622-02. Left out of zip file. Discussion of best real fix indicate that a -03 version with a different approach creating a single ATNA section referring to DICOM, and referring to that from all the other sections, will be best.
- Can Mike Henderson take 623?
- CP-ITI-526 (XDS-SD and BPPC), 412 (DSIG), will be affected by document supplement new profile and content profile normalization. It will be able to proceed when a new content profile template is released.
- CP-ITI-612 (need to add missing final digit "6" to UUID), just fix the typo as part of Final Text integration.
May 5, 2012
Face to Face (Oak Brook), Tuesday Prepare Ballot #15
- CP's in Ballot #15
- CP-516
- CP-527
- CP-606
- CP-622-02
- CP-637-01
- CP-640-02
- CP-641-00
- CP-642-00
May 4, 2012
Face to Face (Oak Brook), Tuesday Ballot Review Results
- Agenda
- Finish Ballot review
Feedback on CP-616 Feedback on CP-606
- Discussion of Assigned
- CP-632
Add requirement to complete registration of the document prior to responding to the retrieve.
- CP-601
Discussed changes indicated in HPD document in Assigned Directory. Karen will update as appropriate.
May 2, 2012
Face to Face (Oak Brook), Tuesday Ballot Review Results
Ballot 14
CP | Title | Outcome (as of end of Monday) |
---|---|---|
414 | IHE ITI TF Vol 2: Appendix L | Approved with one typo fix |
504 | XDR Actors support Async Option | Approved |
516 | Correct hyperlinks to point to TF sections | Reject due to incorrect ballot text, put in Ballot #15 |
524 | Included in ballot package by error | Already approved in Ballot #13 |
527 | Remove *CodeDisplayName Registry enforcement | Reject. Revise rationale based on comment and place in Ballot #15 |
550 | Additional XDR errorCode values | Reject. Revise to have one generic error, not a growing list of specific error codes. |
587 | Remove specialization of UserIsRequestor | Reject. Not ready. Put back to assigned. |
589 | ATNA Encrypttion Reference in XDS Vol1 Security Considerations | Approved |
606 | XUA++ Authz-Consent Option | Rewritten, re-ballot in Ballot #15 |
616 | HPD Query and Feed operations use same parameter type | Reject based on Forcare comment, put back to Assigned |
618 | XUA++ Authz-Consent Option - XACML Solution | Rejected, not ready. |
626 | Typos in table 4.1-8 Document Metadata Attribute Enforcement | Rejected. "Hash enforcement" needs definition |
627 | Author metadata attribute should not allow author with only a role or specialty | Approved with IBM comment addition "at least one of the following subattributes must be present" |
628 | authorTelecommunication attribute should be multi-valued | Approved |
631 | XDSExtraMetadataNotSaved code inconsistent | Approved |
636 | XDS-SD Support for Character Set Encoding for plain text | Approved |
April 13, 2012
1000h Central
Agenda
- Incoming CP Discussions
- Async Supplement update to APpendix V ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-Async-update-to-Appx.V.doc
This is an approved supplement edit that got lost in editorial inclusion. Give this number 638 and move directly to final text.
- HPD Errors and inconsistencies ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-HPD-Errors.doc
Leave in incoming until we can find an editor. Revisit at face to face.
Outdated
- Clarify option requirements in XDW ftp://@ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-XDW-clarifyOptionRqmts-20120330.docx
Assign CP-640
- Define Code for Workflow Status in eventCodeList ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance-2012/CPs/Incoming/CP-ITI-XDW-createCodeForWorkflowStatus.docx
Assign CP-641
This should be the updated version of 637. Review again at F2F. Priority for next ballot.
- Discuss CPs
- Ballot Discussion
- ITI-CP-414-03 IHE ITI TF Vol 2: Appendix L
- ITI-CP-504-02 XDR Actors support Async Option
- ITI-CP-516-01 Correct hyperlinks to point to TF sections
ITI-CP-516-00 ended up in ballot package.
ITI-CP-524 was in Ballot-13 and should not be in the ZIP file or spreadsheet.
- ITI-CP-527-01 Remove CodeDisplayName registry enforcement
- ITI-CP-550-00 Additional XDR errorCode values
- ITI-CP-587-00 Remove specialization of UserIsRequestor
Not ready, there are no changes.
- ITI-CP-589-01 ATNA Encryption Reference in XDS Vol 1 Security Considerations
- ITI-CP-606-00 Simple solution to XUA++ Authz-Consent option
- ITI-CP-616-02 HPD Query and Feed operations use same parameter type
- ITI-CP-618-01 XUA++ Authz-Consent Option, XACML solution
Confusion during previous tcon. 606 was ready. 618 should wait. (Authors had to drop out before tcon ended.)
- ITI-CP-626-00 Typos in table 4.1-8
- ITI-CP-627-00 Author metadata attribute should not allow author elements with only a role or specialty
- ITI-CP-628-00 authorTelecommunication attribute should be multivalued
- ITI-CP-631-00 XDSExtraMetadataNotSaved code inconsistent
- ITI-CP-636-01 XDS-SD Support for Character Set Encoding for plain text
- Ready for Integration
- ITI-CP-524-FT XDS Metadata author and intended recipient extension
- ITI-CP-536-FT Datatype Typos
- ITI-CP-573-FT Remove XForms Option
- ITI-CP-577-FT Is SourcePatientID single or multi-valued (Missed from integration step of August Publication)
- ITI-CP-600-FT Change table 4.1.9 Folder metadata for including “Deprecated availabilityStatus”
- ITI-CP-602-FT XUA Extension Subject:role version
- ITI-CP-603-FT Update expected Actions when Document Recipient receives metadata error
- ITI-CP-604-FT Correct outdated reference to Audit Trail message payload schema
- ITI-CP-605-FT Error message on size mismatch
- ITI-CP-607-FT Extension On Media Encryption
- ITI-CP-608-FT ZIP Over Email
- ITI-CP-609-FT ZIP Over Email Response
- ITI-CP-612-FT DSUB Specific Query UUID
- ITI-CP-619-FT XCPD WSDL elements not adequately defined
Minutes
March 9, 2012
1000h Central
Agenda
- Incoming CP Discussions
- CP-ITI-LF-XDW-corrections Address XDW inconsistencies
- Discuss CPs
- ITI-CP-543-01 Additional XDR errorCode values
- ITI-CP-551-01 DSG URN Clarification
- Ready for Ballot
- ITI-CP-414-03 IHE ITI TF Vol 2: Appendix L
- ITI-CP-504-02 XDR Actors support Async Option
- ITI-CP-516-01 Correct hyperlinks to point to TF sections
- ITI-CP-527-01 Remove CodeDisplayName registry enforcement
- ITI-CP-550-00 Additional XDR errorCode values
- ITI-CP-587-00 Remove specialization of UserIsRequestor
- ITI-CP-589-01 ATNA Encryption Reference in XDS Vol 1 Security Considerations
- ITI-CP-606-00 Simple solution to XUA++ Authz-Consent option
- ITI-CP-616-02 HPD Query and Feed operations use same parameter type
- ITI-CP-618-01 XUA++ Authz-Consent Option, XACML solution
- ITI-CP-626-00 Typos in table 4.1-8
- ITI-CP-627-00 Author metadata attribute should not allow author elements with only a role or specialty
- ITI-CP-628-00 authorTelecommunication attribute should be multivalued
- ITI-CP-631-00 XDSExtraMetadataNotSaved code inconsistent
- ITI-CP-636-01 XDS-SD Support for Character Set Encoding for plain text
- Ready for Integration
- ITI-CP-524-FT XDS Metadata author and intended recipient extension
- ITI-CP-536-FT Datatype Typos
- ITI-CP-573-FT Remove XForms Option
- ITI-CP-577-FT Is SourcePatientID single or multi-valued (Missed from integration step of August Publication)
- ITI-CP-600-FT Change table 4.1.9 Folder metadata for including “Deprecated availabilityStatus”
- ITI-CP-602-FT XUA Extension Subject:role version
- ITI-CP-603-FT Update expected Actions when Document Recipient receives metadata error
- ITI-CP-604-FT Correct outdated reference to Audit Trail message payload schema
- ITI-CP-605-FT Error message on size mismatch
- ITI-CP-607-FT Extension On Media Encryption
- ITI-CP-608-FT ZIP Over Email
- ITI-CP-609-FT ZIP Over Email Response
- ITI-CP-612-FT DSUB Specific Query UUID
- ITI-CP-619-FT XCPD WSDL elements not adequately defined
Minutes
- Issue Ballot
- Discussed CPs
- 543 discussed, new version, work to be done in comments
- 551 discussed, decided to define a urn for II data-type (OID+extension)
- 622 discussed, will add fixes for supplements also. Reference format is correct.
- New CPs
- ITI-CP-637 Address XDW inconsistencies
January 06, 2012
0900h Central
Agenda
- Incoming CP Discussions
- Discuss CP-632
- Write CPs especially Security CPs
- Ready for Ballot
- ITI-CP-504-02 XDR Actors support Async Option
- Ready for Integration
- ITI-CP-577-FT (Missed from integration step of August Publication)
- People and number of CPs in Assigned
| Assigned editor | Number of CPs | |-------------------+---------------| | Bill Majurski | 27 | | Elliott Lavy | 3 | | Geoff Pascoe | 1 | | John Moehrke | 11 (one f2f) | | Karen Witting | 3 | | Lynn Felhofer | 2 | | Manual Metz | 1 | | Mark Sinke | 3 | | Massimiliano Masi | 1 | | Rob Horn | 14 | | Vassil Peytchev | 7 | | Walco van Loon | 5 | | Dan Trainor | 3 | | | |