Quality, Research and Public Health Technical Committee/Review Guidance

From IHE Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

In QRPH, reviewers can use the following helpful guidelines to help them start the review process.

Please work with the Technical Co-chairs to add to this list. We always welcome your input to improve this process.

  • Did the authors speak with stakeholders? Were the stakeholders involved in the process?
  • Is the non technical introduction easy to understand (by non-developers)? Does it clearly describe the problem the profile is trying to solve?
  • Does the profile supplement conform to current IHE template used by QRPH? Are all the sections and tables / figures numbered correctly?
  • Does the document make sense? Can a new implementer understand the flow?
  • Do the Process flow diagrams and the Actor-transaction diagrams make sense? Are they technically correct?
  • Are use cases and actors/transactions/content correctly defined?