ITI Planning Committee 2008/09 Webinars

From IHE Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Introduction

This WIKI page documents 2008/09 Brief Profile proposals for the ITI Planning Domain. In total, 15 proposals have been submitted by the prescribed deadline (26Sep08, COB), and this is the group of candidate standards that we will proceed with.

Note that profile proposals will be reviewed, and combined if necessary, during Webinars to be held October 1, 2, 7 and 8. Details on each webinar can be found below.

Voting Privileges

As a reminder, we are in the first year of the implementation of IHE’s new Governance Structure and Procedures, and this has required a number of changes to membership and processes within the Domain committees. Here are a few basic rules:

  • In order to participate in the ITI Planning meetings, you must first be a delegate of an approved IHE member organization. Membership is granted only to “organizations”, and each member names delegates (primary and alternate) to participate in various domain committees. So, please check the membership list to ensure your organization is a bona fide member of IHE. If not, then you can apply for membership (it’s free) using this webpage.
  • Any member is entitled to send a delegate to attend a meeting. However, in order to vote, the member (organization) must have earned (and maintained) voting privileges prior to the designated meeting. The rules around voting privileges are articulated on the ihe website, but explained below in the context of the upcoming ITI Planning Committee face-to-face, as follows:
  • If a member (organization) attends the one t-con immediately prior to the face-to-face meeting, they'll have voting privileges at that meeting.
  • If a member attends any two consecutive t-cons prior to the face-to-face meeting, they'll have voting privileges at that meeting (assuming they haven't skipped three in a row in the meantime).

Recognizing all of this, we have established some specific procedures leading up to the October f2f meeting in Paris, so please make sure you fully comprehend and follow the instructions below, to ensure you will have the right to vote at the meeting. These are:

  • Webinars have been announced for October 1, 2, 7 and 8 (see below), to allow authors to present their proposals to the ITI Planning Committee in advance of the face-to-face. These webinars will all be recorded, and we will publish the links immediately following each webinar.
  • These webinars will be considered decision meetings. We will attempt to reach consensus (rather than hold a formal vote) at each webinar as to the validity of each individual proposal, including whether it makes sense to request proposal authors to combine initiatives where overlaps exist. No proposals will be rejected at this stage, only aligned with one another, and only where appropriate.
  • In order to ensure voting privileges at the face-to-face meeting in Paris, we will require each member (organization) to attend a minimum of 2 (out of the 4) webinars that precede the Paris meeting. We will be taking very careful attendance at each webinar to ensure a fair execution of this process. Please ensure you clearly understand this requirement.

Webinar Organization

Each webinar will be organized as follows (this will vary slightly depending upon how many proposals we will be reviewing:

  • The two hour time allocation will be divided into 6x15-minute time-slots, with the remaining 30 minutes for introductory remarks and follow-up discussion.
  • Each 15-minute timeslot will be allocated to a profile proposal… the first 10 minutes will be taken up by a presentation by the proposal author, with the remaining 5 minutes reserved for discussion and any disposition (if required). In order to maintain equity across all presenters, we will manage this time rigorously!!!
  • Each 10-minute presentation will be comprised of a maximum of 5 Powerpoint slides, presenting the proposal concisely and completely. We have taken the liberty of supplying a presentation template that you may choose to use, and this can be found in the following folder on the IHE ftp site.

Webinar #1 AGENDA

Date Time Recorded Presentation
1-Oct-08 10:00-noon CDT Click to play
# Proposal Author/Presenter Description Time Comments
ITI 1.0 FTP Link KassnerA; CaumannsJ Identification Protection Token (PAT) 10:10-10:25 The authors will seek clarity on this proposal using the ITI Planning GoogleGroup. Discussion will be scheduled for Webinar #4 to consider potential overlaps between this proposal and ITI 14.0 (presented in Webinar #3). Link to presentation
ITI 2.0 FTP Link WittingK Cross-Community Patient Identification (XCPI) 10:25-10:40 Link to presentation
ITI 4.0 FTP Link KassnerA; CaumannsJ Federated Service White Pages (FSWP) 10:40-10:55 Authors agred to clarify boundaries between FSWP and FOR Profile Proposals, and revise each proposal accordingly. Link to presentation
ITI 5.0 FTP Link KassnerA; CaumannsJ Cross-Enterprise Privacy Policy (XPP) 10:55-11:10 Link to presentation
ITI 6.0 FTP Link KassnerA; CaumannsJ Federated Organisation Registry (FOR) 11:10-11:25 Authors agred to clarify boundaries between FSWP and FOR Profile Proposals, and revise each proposal accordingly. Link to presentation

Webinar #2 AGENDA

Date Time Recorded Presentation
2-Oct-08 10:00-noon CDT Click to play
# Proposal Author/Presenter Description Time Comments
ITI 12.0 FTP Link KirnakA; NatoliJ; OrlovaA Service-Aware PIX and PDQ 10:10-10:25 Link to presentation
ITI 8.0 FTP Link PaytchevV Cross-enterprise Document Query (XDQ) 10:25-10:40 Link to presentation
ITI 9.0 Wiki Link PeychevV ITI Publish/Subscribe Infrastructure 10:40-10:55 Link to presentation
ITI 10.0 FTP Link OemigF XDS Document Linkng 10:55-11:10 Link to presentation
ITI 11.0 FTP Link KassnerA; CaumannsJ XDS-P2P 11:10-11:25 Discussion will be scheduled for Webinar #4 to consider potential overlaps between this proposal and ITI6.0/ITI8.0. Link to presentation
ITI 7.0 FTP Link KirnakA; NatoliJ; OrlovaA XDS.c 11:25-11:40 Link to presentation

Webinar #3 AGENDA

Date Time Recorded Presentation
7-Oct-08 10:00-noon CDT Click to play
# Proposal Author/Presenter Description Time Comments
ITI 13.0 FTP Link KirnakA; NatoliJ; OrlovaA Decision Support Service 10:10-10:25 Additional information to be supplied expanding on use cases reflecting the content supported by the proposed decision support service. In addition, links will be provided articulating architectural perspective. Link to presentation
ITI 14.0 FTP Link EstelrichA Use of Pseudonymisation and De-Identification in IHE Profiles 10:25-10:40 Link to presentation
ITI 15.0 FTP Link EstelrichA XDS Stored Query – Multi-patient Queries 10:40-10:55 Link to presentation
ITI 3.0 Wiki Link O'DonnellK; NagyP Critical and Important Results (Findings Notification and Logging) 10:55-11:10 Link to presentation

Webinar #4 AGENDA

Date Time Recorded Presentation
8-Oct-08 10:00-noon CDT Click to play
# Proposal Author/Presenter Description Time Comments
ITI1.0/ITI14.0 ITI Planning Committee Discussion on ITI 1.0 (IPT), TI2.0 (XCPI) and ITI 14.0 (Pseudonymisation)to consider potential overlaps. 10:10-10:25 Resolved that IPT will be included as part of the Pseudonymisation White Paper. Joerg and Ana to re-draft White Paper brief proposal document to accommodate combination and to note overlaps with XCPI profile proposal (to go forward as is). IPT Update IPT/PAT/QRPH Discussion
ITI11.0/ITI6.0/ITI8.0 ITI Planning Committee Discussion on ITI11.0 (XDS-P2P), ITI6.0 (FOR) and ITI8.0 (XDQ) to consider potential overlaps. 10:25-10:40 The authors responded to previous webinar questions on P2P, and agreed to re-submit as a white paper proposal concentrating on Use Case #2 (multiple records for different purposes). Also, it was agreed to combine FOR & FSWP proposals, but as a profile proposal rather than a white paper. Consideration to previous ITI work on Configuration (Rob Horn) will be included. Brief proposals to be resubmitted as ammended. XDS-P2P Response to Questions FOR-FSWP Combining discussion
ITI13.0 ITI Planning Committee Discussion on ITI13.0 Decision Support Service - consideration of comments from PCC Planning. 10:40-10:55 Members of the PCC Planning Committee joined to discuss proposals being considered around Decision Support. The authors reiterated that the ITI proposal was to look at SOA, therefore solely related to infrastructure (along with 2 other proposals), and as such, it was agreed to leave the profile proposal as-is. The authors agreed to propose profiling (1) interface and (2) payload, but to scope out (3) rules at this stage. Alignment with initiatives in PCC, Lab and QRPH will be ensured. Brief proposal to be resubmitted as ammended.

ITI Planning Committee f2f - 16-17Oct08 AGENDA

THURSDAY - DAY 1

Location Webex/Tcon
UICP
16 rue Jean Rey
75015 Paris
Paris hotels
  • Join Meeting
  • Meeting #: 924 288 985
  • pw=meeting
  • Dial-in only: 1-866-469-3239, 1-650-429-3300
Agenda # Time/Description
LUNCH noon - 1:00pm Paris time (5:00-6:00am CT) - meet at the meeting room, then we'll procede to the restaurant as a group.
Restaurant: Hotel Mercure, 20 rue Jean Rey
(Restaurant is about 10 yards on the right when exiting the meeting room building. If you arrive late, go directly to the restaurant and ask for the IHE meeting.)
1. Welcome 1:00 - 1:30pm Paris time (6:00-6:30am CT)
  • Introductions
  • Housekeeping
  • Procedures, voting privileges, etc.
2. Organization of Work 1:30-2:30pm Paris time (6:30-7:30am CT)
  • Supplements in Trial Implementation
  • New Profile proposals
  • New proposals for White papers
  • White papers published by TC - which should go forward to full profile this year?
  • White Papers in progress
  • Planned continued development of existing profiles
  • Retirement of Profiles
  • Capacity of ITI for new profile/white paper proposals (decision)
  • IT Infrastructure Roadmap - proposal for renewal
3. Advocacy - authors & representatives make a case for each proposal 2:30 - 3:30pm Paris time (7:30-8:30am CT)
  • Supplements expected to move to final text and Technical Framework update
  • New profile proposals (15min of discussion per proposal)
  • New proposals for White Papers (15min of discussion per proposal)
(Please ensure you have attended/viewed each of the 4 Webinars prior to this session)
BREAK 3:30 - 4:00pm Paris time (8:30-9:00am CT)
4. Advocacy (continued) 4:00 - 7:30pm Paris time (9:00am -12:30pm CT)
5. Wrap-up of the day 7:30 - 8:00pm Paris time (12:30-1:00pm CT)
ADJOURN 8:00pm Paris time (1:00pm CT)
.
.

FRIDAY - DAY 2

Location Webex/Tcon
UICP
16 rue Jean Rey
75015 Paris
  • Join Meeting
  • Meeting #: 921 286 032
  • pw=meeting
  • Dial-in only: 1-866-469-3239, 1-650-429-3300
Agenda # Time/Description
1. Welcome, review of the day's plan 10:00 - 10:30am Paris time (3:00-3:30am CT)
2. Discussion and decision on which items go forward 10:30am - 1:00pm Paris time (3:30-6:00am CT)

including consideration of

  • relationship to external initiatives (ie. HITSP)
  • scope vs availability of resources
  • relationship to activities in other IHE domains
LUNCH 1:00 - 2:00pm Paris time (6:00-7:00am CT)
Restaurant: Hotel Mercure, 20 rue Jean Rey
3. Discussion and decision on which items go forward 2:00-4:30pm Paris time (7:00-9:30am CT)
BREAK 4:30 - 5:00pm Paris time (9:30-10:00am CT)
4. Update of ITI Roadmap reflecting new work item decisions 5:00 - 6:00pm Paris time (10:00-11:00am CT)
  • New items for 2008-2009
  • Items to be referred to / partnered with other IHE Domains
  • Items to be referred to SDO’s for needed work
5. Next Steps 6:00 - 6:45pm Paris time (11:00am -11:45pm CT)
  • Assignment of authors, due-dates, etc. for completion of Detailed Proposal (due date TBA) for turn-over to TC in November (ITI Tech meets Nov 18-19, 2008 for a f2f)
  • Schedule follow-up t-cons
  • Marketing and publicity planning
  • Preparation for meeting at HIMSS (harmonization with HITSP, other standards initiatives)
  • Publication schedule
  • Other
6. Wrap-up 6:45 - 7:00pm Paris time (11:45-noon CT)
ADJOURN 7:00pm Paris time (noon CT)
.
.

ITI Planning Paris f2f Meeting Results

On October 16-17, 2008, we held a very successful 2-day Planning Committee meeting in Paris, France. The turnout was better than expected, and all IHE deployment regions (Asia-Oceana, North America, Europe) were represented. We even had a number of call-in members from the US who amazingly managed to stay up all night in order to participate… now that’s commitment!!! Manuel Metz and the team from GIP-DMP were incredible hosts, and on behalf of all participants, we thank our newest domain sponsor for accommodating us in such grand style. The bar has, indeed, been raised to new heights!!!

In total we had 15 proposals submitted for consideration, each one very well researched and presented at pre-meeting webinars. We undertook a process of review and consolidation going into the meeting, and our subsequent deliberations further flushed out those proposals that were felt to be of highest priority. We thank all authors for their excellent efforts… the choices were incredibly difficult due to the high quality of the proposals submitted. It is unfortunate that we were only able to select a few of them… limited only by the capacity of our domain to undertake work over the next 12 months.

Mike Nusbaum and Charles Parisot (co-Chairs) are pleased to announce that 5 profile proposals and 2 white paper proposals were accepted by the Planning Committee to go forward to the next step in the process. These are outlined in the table below. Congratulations to the authors who were successful in having their profiles selected.

Priority Proposal Title Principal Author
1 ITI Publish/Subscribe Infrastructure Peytchev, V.
2 Cross-Community Patient Identification (XCPI) Witting, K.
3 Use of Pseudonymisation, de-Identification and Identification Protection Token in IHE (White Paper) Estelrich, A.
4 Expanded SOA (White Paper) Kirnak, A.; Natoli, J.; Orlova, A.
5 Cross-Enterprise Privacy Policy (XPP) Kassner, A.; Caumanns, J.
6 Federated Service White Pages (FSWP)/Organisation Registry (FOR) Kassner, A.; Caumanns, J.
7 Multi-Stored Query - Multi-Patient Queries Estelrich, A.

A spreadsheet providing details on those proposals selected can be found here. All selected (brief) profile proposal documents can be found in this directory on the FTP site, for reference.

The Technical Committees meet jointly face-to-face on November 18th and 19th (in Chicago) to evaluate the selection of the proposals that will ultimately become the work plan for the 2009/10 development cycle. Details of the meeting can be found here. The ITI Planning and ITI Technical Committee will jointly hold a t-con on December 17th to make the final decision for the 2009/2010 development cycle to be carried by the ITI Technical Committee in 2009.

Thanks to all who participated in this truly international process. We look forward to a very productive year ahead of us in ITI.