Checkpoint Assessment: Difference between revisions

From IHE Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Created page with "===AISCap Kickoff Assessment === * Profile Name: AISPro ** Describe gaps in Use Case coverage *** Handling of additional information use cases (e.g. prior studies or prior AI results) ** Review ALL "uncertainty points" in the evaluation. Is there a resolution plan for each? ** Do the effort points in the evaluation still seem right? ** Did the Breakdown of Tasks accurately reflect the work? What extra tasks arose? *** Due to decision to use Questionaire and Questionai..."
 
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
===AISCap Kickoff Assessment ===
===AISPro Kickoff Assessment ===




* Profile Name: AISPro
* Profile Name: AISPro (AI Service Properties)
** Describe gaps in Use Case coverage
** Describe gaps in Use Case coverage
*** Handling of additional information use cases (e.g. prior studies or prior AI results)
*** Handling of additional information use cases (e.g. prior studies or prior AI results). What is the best way to encode information that a prior study or additional input objects are needed.
** Review ALL "uncertainty points" in the evaluation. Is there a resolution plan for each?
** Review ALL "uncertainty points" in the evaluation. Is there a resolution plan for each?
*** Yes there is resolution for uncertainty found during profile selection
*** Additional uncertainty arises due to the gap mentioned above
** Do the effort points in the evaluation still seem right?  
** Do the effort points in the evaluation still seem right?  
*** The effort estimation seems about right
** Did the Breakdown of Tasks accurately reflect the work? What extra tasks arose?
** Did the Breakdown of Tasks accurately reflect the work? What extra tasks arose?
*** Due to decision to use Questionaire and QuestionaireResponse
*** Due to decision to use Questionaire and QuestionaireResponse additional effort will be needed for defining the content of the resources as well as for the new transaction associated with the exchange
*** Also an additional actor is foreseen now
** Describe unresolved technical issues/tasks
** Describe unresolved technical issues/tasks
*** handling of ultracomplex input requirements
*** no unresolved technical issues identified
** Describe potential practical issues
** Describe potential practical issues
** Review the open issue list. Does it feel complete
** Review the open issue list. Does it feel complete
*** One open issue was identified.
** Which open issues feel most risky; what other risks exist?
** Which open issues feel most risky; what other risks exist?
*** The open issue is not related to any risk
*** no additional risks identified at this point
** How is the work fitting in the allocated bandwidth? (Time to spare? Just right? Things were left undone?)
** How is the work fitting in the allocated bandwidth? (Time to spare? Just right? Things were left undone?)
*** a little time to spare during this meeting
** How does the scope feel? (Room to expand? Just right? Pretty ambitious?)
** How does the scope feel? (Room to expand? Just right? Pretty ambitious?)
*** expanded the scope during kickoff and no further expansion would be appropriate
** If you had to reduce scope, what would you drop?
** If you had to reduce scope, what would you drop?
*** N/A
** Have the promised resources manifested?
** Have the promised resources manifested?
*** Yes
** What tasks would benefit from additional expertise?
** What tasks would benefit from additional expertise?
*** Content definition of FHIR Resources. Promised resources are expected to be suffucient
** What implementers are engaged for each actor? Record how many.
** What implementers are engaged for each actor? Record how many.
*** Rough estimate are 5 vendors from AIGI workgroup
** Was the profile where it needed to be at the start of the Kickoff meeting (See "Kickoff Meeting" above), if not what was the gap
** Was the profile where it needed to be at the start of the Kickoff meeting (See "Kickoff Meeting" above), if not what was the gap
*** Yes
** Was the profile where it needed to be at the end of the Kickoff meeting, if not what was the gap
** Was the profile where it needed to be at the end of the Kickoff meeting, if not what was the gap
*** Yes
** How many tcons would you like between now and the PC Prep Meeting?
** How many tcons would you like between now and the PC Prep Meeting?
 
*** Two. December 17 9a.m. CST and January 21. at 9a.m CST
It will be the responsibility of the Profile Editor to lead resolution of these issues before the Public Comment preparation meeting.
 
Resolution may involve:
* Scheduling additional Tcons to complete the technical discussion
* Reducing the scope of the profile to fit within the allocated % bandwidth
* Including open issues in the PC Profile draft for wider comment (generally for issues that would not radically change the profile)
* Changing the workitem from a profile to a whitepaper to explore the solution space if it is not ready for profiling.  
** Hopefully the whitepaper work is solid enough that it will be ready to profile next year and the same proposal will be selected again
* Dismissing the workitem as not ready for profiling in the forseeable future.
** This likely means there was something the TC should have caught during evaluation

Latest revision as of 14:21, 12 November 2026

AISPro Kickoff Assessment

  • Profile Name: AISPro (AI Service Properties)
    • Describe gaps in Use Case coverage
      • Handling of additional information use cases (e.g. prior studies or prior AI results). What is the best way to encode information that a prior study or additional input objects are needed.
    • Review ALL "uncertainty points" in the evaluation. Is there a resolution plan for each?
      • Yes there is resolution for uncertainty found during profile selection
      • Additional uncertainty arises due to the gap mentioned above
    • Do the effort points in the evaluation still seem right?
      • The effort estimation seems about right
    • Did the Breakdown of Tasks accurately reflect the work? What extra tasks arose?
      • Due to decision to use Questionaire and QuestionaireResponse additional effort will be needed for defining the content of the resources as well as for the new transaction associated with the exchange
      • Also an additional actor is foreseen now
    • Describe unresolved technical issues/tasks
      • no unresolved technical issues identified
    • Describe potential practical issues
    • Review the open issue list. Does it feel complete
      • One open issue was identified.
    • Which open issues feel most risky; what other risks exist?
      • The open issue is not related to any risk
      • no additional risks identified at this point
    • How is the work fitting in the allocated bandwidth? (Time to spare? Just right? Things were left undone?)
      • a little time to spare during this meeting
    • How does the scope feel? (Room to expand? Just right? Pretty ambitious?)
      • expanded the scope during kickoff and no further expansion would be appropriate
    • If you had to reduce scope, what would you drop?
      • N/A
    • Have the promised resources manifested?
      • Yes
    • What tasks would benefit from additional expertise?
      • Content definition of FHIR Resources. Promised resources are expected to be suffucient
    • What implementers are engaged for each actor? Record how many.
      • Rough estimate are 5 vendors from AIGI workgroup
    • Was the profile where it needed to be at the start of the Kickoff meeting (See "Kickoff Meeting" above), if not what was the gap
      • Yes
    • Was the profile where it needed to be at the end of the Kickoff meeting, if not what was the gap
      • Yes
    • How many tcons would you like between now and the PC Prep Meeting?
      • Two. December 17 9a.m. CST and January 21. at 9a.m CST