Radiology Proposals 2025-2026: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Stevenichols (talk | contribs) |
|||
| (16 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
==Final Selection== | ==Final Selection== | ||
The Planning Committee selected the following proposals on '''[[Rad_Plan_Minutes_2022-10-01|Oct 1, 2025]]''' | |||
:* A. [[RAD TF Maintenance 2025-2026]] (20%) | |||
:* B. [[Imaging Diagnostic Report (Phase II) - Proposal]] Full 45%, | |||
:* C. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ik7Na2bcivsXzBGNUfG3D3fWrngiXycn/edit?usp=share_link&ouid=111306937438382146052&rtpof=true&sd=true Manifest-Based Access to DICOM Objects (MADO)] Full 35% | |||
==Effort Assessment== | ==Effort Assessment== | ||
(to | The Technical Committee evaluated the required effort of the Detailed Proposals as follows in tcons on [[Rad_Tech_Minutes_2025-09-03 | Sep 29]], [[Rad_Tech_Minutes_2025-09-09 | Sep 9]], & [[Rad_Tech_Minutes_2025-09-17 | Sept 17]]. | ||
Results: '''[https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1cb4GpTZgdp0UDooS__PBLhkoedozVaI7X26k-swDEmA/edit?usp=sharing Assessment Spreadsheet]''' | |||
:* A. [[RAD TF Maintenance 2025-2026]] (20%) | |||
:* B. [[Imaging Diagnostic Report (Phase II) - Proposal]] Full 45%, Min 35% | |||
:* C. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ik7Na2bcivsXzBGNUfG3D3fWrngiXycn/edit?usp=share_link&ouid=111306937438382146052&rtpof=true&sd=true Manifest-Based Access to DICOM Objects (MADO)] Full 35%, Min 25% | |||
:* D. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/14mU8kOiLZS-p3H11p456zQVAVexuSyZTB9ruz0h-Qm0/edit?usp=sharing Radiation Exposure Monitoring - Patient (REM - PRDSR)] - Full 20% Min 15% | |||
:* E. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1AvVJjxD3tCvIBETfHpFz2K8G_SY4AO3C/edit?usp=share_link&ouid=111306937438382146052&rtpof=true&sd=true AI Metadata Index] Full 40%, Min 35% | |||
See [[Proposal Effort Evaluation#TC Review & Effort Estimation|Proposal Effort Evaluation]] for evaluation guidance. | |||
==Detailed Proposals== | ==Detailed Proposals== | ||
Submitted by the August 26, 2025 deadline. | |||
:* A. [[RAD TF Maintenance 2025-2026]] | |||
:* B. [[Imaging Diagnostic Report (Phase II) - Proposal]] | |||
:* C. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ik7Na2bcivsXzBGNUfG3D3fWrngiXycn/edit?usp=share_link&ouid=111306937438382146052&rtpof=true&sd=true Manifest-Based Access to DICOM Objects (MADO)] | |||
:* D.[https://docs.google.com/document/d/14mU8kOiLZS-p3H11p456zQVAVexuSyZTB9ruz0h-Qm0/edit?usp=sharing Radiation Exposure Monitoring - Patient (REM - PRDSR)] | |||
:* E. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1AvVJjxD3tCvIBETfHpFz2K8G_SY4AO3C/edit?usp=share_link&ouid=111306937438382146052&rtpof=true&sd=true AI Metadata Index] | |||
==Short Listing== | ==Short Listing== | ||
'''[[Rad_Plan_Minutes_2025-08-05|On Aug 5, 2025]]''', the Planning Committee selected a shortlist of Brief Proposals. | |||
All 4 submitted proposals will be assessed by the [[Radiology Technical Committee]]. | |||
They were provisionally ranked: | |||
:# (32 pts) Imaging Diagnostic Report(Phase II) | |||
:# (28 pts) Manifest-Based Access to DICOM Objects (MADO) | |||
:# (15 pts) Radiology AI Metadata Index | |||
:# ( 9 pts) Radiation Exposure Monitoring Patient (REM – PRDSR) | |||
==Brief Proposals== | ==Brief Proposals== | ||
Submitted by '''July 21, 2025'''. | Submitted by '''July 21, 2025 11:59pm''' deadline. | ||
:* (A. Maintenance) | :* (A. Maintenance) | ||
:* B. [[Imaging Diagnostic Report (Phase II) - Proposal]] | :* B. [[Imaging Diagnostic Report (Phase II) - Proposal]] | ||
:* C. [https://wiki.ihe.net/uploads/5/56/IHE_Profile_Proposal_Manifest-Access-Imaging_Objects-Brief-V5.doc Manifest-Based Access to DICOM Objects (MADO)] | :* C. [https://wiki.ihe.net/uploads/5/56/IHE_Profile_Proposal_Manifest-Access-Imaging_Objects-Brief-V5.doc Manifest-Based Access to DICOM Objects (MADO)] | ||
:* D. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/14mU8kOiLZS-p3H11p456zQVAVexuSyZTB9ruz0h-Qm0/edit?usp=sharing Radiation Exposure Monitoring - Patient (REM - PRDSR)] | |||
:* E. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1WNjCdOpXY5ZixSzGo-snRJmGq9T_NrOSVs_CaEeIQW0/edit?usp=sharing Radiology AI Metadata Index] | |||
==Process== | ==Process== | ||
| Line 28: | Line 55: | ||
Contact radiology@ihe.net with any questions. | Contact radiology@ihe.net with any questions. | ||
===2. Shortlisting=== | |||
The Planning Committee schedules a Shortlisting call. | |||
Proposal Editors present their proposals to the Planning Committee who votes to select a shortlist of Brief Proposals. | |||
=== | ===3. Detailed Proposals=== | ||
(For proposals on the shortlist) Proposal Editors expand their proposal into a Detailed Proposal. | |||
* '''Expand your Brief Proposal''' to include Detailed Proposal elements | * '''Expand your Brief Proposal''' to include Detailed Proposal elements | ||
:* Copy the [[Delta Proposal Template]] into the bottom of your proposal page | :* Copy the [[Delta Proposal Template]] into the bottom of your proposal page | ||
:* Update as described in the Delta Template (adds Summary, Technical Details, Evaluation, etc.) | :* Update as described in the Delta Template (adds Summary, Technical Details, Evaluation, etc.) | ||
* '''Complete the Breakdown of Tasks''' with a strawman estimate of story points | |||
* Your goal is to give sufficient detail for the Tech Cmte to be able to evaluate the technical feasibility, specification tasks and effort required. | * Your goal is to give sufficient detail for the Tech Cmte to be able to evaluate the technical feasibility, specification tasks and effort required. | ||
'''Reviewers''' | '''Reviewers''' can enter comments under Risks and Decisions/Topics/Uncertainties section of the proposal. | ||
===4. Effort Evaluations=== | |||
The Technical Committee schedules a series of '''[[Proposal Effort Evaluation]]''' calls and assigns slots to each Proposal Editor. | |||
* Proposal Editors present the Technical Details and Breakdown of Tasks. | |||
* Tech Cmte members review, comment, and help refine both the content of the Breakdown of Tasks and the "Story Point" estimates. | |||
* Tech Cmte records evaluations at the bottom of each detailed proposal. | |||
=== | ===5. Final Selection=== | ||
The | The Planning Committee schedules a Final Selection call. | ||
Proposal Editors present their proposal summary, risks, and effort assessments to the Planning Committee. | |||
The Planning Committee votes to make a final selection of Proposals for work this cycle. | |||
Latest revision as of 13:35, 9 October 2025
Final Selection
The Planning Committee selected the following proposals on Oct 1, 2025
- A. RAD TF Maintenance 2025-2026 (20%)
- B. Imaging Diagnostic Report (Phase II) - Proposal Full 45%,
- C. Manifest-Based Access to DICOM Objects (MADO) Full 35%
Effort Assessment
The Technical Committee evaluated the required effort of the Detailed Proposals as follows in tcons on Sep 29, Sep 9, & Sept 17.
Results: Assessment Spreadsheet
- A. RAD TF Maintenance 2025-2026 (20%)
- B. Imaging Diagnostic Report (Phase II) - Proposal Full 45%, Min 35%
- C. Manifest-Based Access to DICOM Objects (MADO) Full 35%, Min 25%
- D. Radiation Exposure Monitoring - Patient (REM - PRDSR) - Full 20% Min 15%
- E. AI Metadata Index Full 40%, Min 35%
See Proposal Effort Evaluation for evaluation guidance.
Detailed Proposals
Submitted by the August 26, 2025 deadline.
Short Listing
On Aug 5, 2025, the Planning Committee selected a shortlist of Brief Proposals.
All 4 submitted proposals will be assessed by the Radiology Technical Committee.
They were provisionally ranked:
- (32 pts) Imaging Diagnostic Report(Phase II)
- (28 pts) Manifest-Based Access to DICOM Objects (MADO)
- (15 pts) Radiology AI Metadata Index
- ( 9 pts) Radiation Exposure Monitoring Patient (REM – PRDSR)
Brief Proposals
Submitted by July 21, 2025 11:59pm deadline.
Process
1. Call for Proposals
Interested parties are invited to submit proposal pages based on the Brief Proposal Template.
You are also welcome to update and resubmit proposals from last year or earlier.
Contact radiology@ihe.net with any questions.
2. Shortlisting
The Planning Committee schedules a Shortlisting call.
Proposal Editors present their proposals to the Planning Committee who votes to select a shortlist of Brief Proposals.
3. Detailed Proposals
(For proposals on the shortlist) Proposal Editors expand their proposal into a Detailed Proposal.
- Expand your Brief Proposal to include Detailed Proposal elements
- Copy the Delta Proposal Template into the bottom of your proposal page
- Update as described in the Delta Template (adds Summary, Technical Details, Evaluation, etc.)
- Complete the Breakdown of Tasks with a strawman estimate of story points
- Your goal is to give sufficient detail for the Tech Cmte to be able to evaluate the technical feasibility, specification tasks and effort required.
Reviewers can enter comments under Risks and Decisions/Topics/Uncertainties section of the proposal.
4. Effort Evaluations
The Technical Committee schedules a series of Proposal Effort Evaluation calls and assigns slots to each Proposal Editor.
- Proposal Editors present the Technical Details and Breakdown of Tasks.
- Tech Cmte members review, comment, and help refine both the content of the Breakdown of Tasks and the "Story Point" estimates.
- Tech Cmte records evaluations at the bottom of each detailed proposal.
5. Final Selection
The Planning Committee schedules a Final Selection call.
Proposal Editors present their proposal summary, risks, and effort assessments to the Planning Committee.
The Planning Committee votes to make a final selection of Proposals for work this cycle.