Difference between revisions of "Radiology Proposals 2019-2020"

From IHE Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(27 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
<!-- COMMENTED OUT TIL LATER - ADD STUFF BELOW
+
 
 
===Final Selection===
 
===Final Selection===
−
The following Proposals are selected by the '''[[Rad_Plan_Minutes_2018-09-24|Planning Committee on Sept 24, 2018]]''' for development work in this cycle.  
+
Final selection by the '''[[Rad Plan Minutes 2019-09-25|Planning Committee on Sept 25, 2019]]''' totaled 105% for development work in this cycle.  
−
 
+
:* Maintenance (35%)
−
:* 40% B. [[Import_and_Display_of_External_Priors-_Proposal]]
+
:* AI Results (25%)
−
:* 30% A. [[Encounter Based Imaging Workflow for Lightweight Devices - Proposal]]
+
:* AI Workflow (45% = 70%-25% for results)
−
:* 30% G. [[Maintenance of Radiology Profiles Published in 2018 and earlier - Brief Proposal]]
 
  
−
The Proposals were ranked as follows by the (link to Planning Committee minute).
+
Candidates:
−
:* B. [[Import_and_Display_of_External_Priors-_Proposal]] - 53 points
+
:* 100%/70% (including the effort for AI Results) A. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1OSYGW0J5YC7wRIkNzWJSCz-VVmtQIu4WGF5gSUF3XsE/edit?usp=sharing Image Based AI Workflow - Detailed Proposal]  
−
:* A. [[Encounter Based Imaging Workflow for Lightweight Devices - Proposal]] - 51 points
+
:* 20%/16% B. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NXa8jq6DthJyF8b1uCUmBGVwuPaZGkGbW-DtVAXYsEI/edit?usp=sharing Contrast Administration Management - Detailed Proposal]  
−
:* C. [[Follow-up of Non Critical Actionable Findings - Proposal]] - 31 points
+
:* 25%/20% C. [[AI Results - Brief Proposal]]
−
:* D. [[Contrast Administration Monitoring - Brief Proposal]] - 10 points
+
:* 35%/35% E. [[RAD TF Maintenance 2019-2020]]
−
:* E. [[Respiratory Correlated Imaging - Brief Proposal]] - 4 points
 
  
−
===Short List/ Detailed Proposals===
+
===Effort Evaluations===
−
The Tech Cmte agreed to evaluate 7 proposals.  The following Proposals were shortlisted by the [[Rad_Plan_Minutes_2018-08-24| Planning Committee on Aug 24, 2018]].
+
The Technical Committee [[Proposal Effort Evaluation|evaluated the required effort]] of the Detailed Proposals as follows in [[Radiology_Technical_Committee#Current_Meetings | tcons on Sept 12, 13 & 16]].
  
−
The Proposals were evaluated by the Tech Cmte, (see TC wiki calendar for details).  
+
:* A. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1OSYGW0J5YC7wRIkNzWJSCz-VVmtQIu4WGF5gSUF3XsE/edit?usp=sharing Image Based AI Workflow - Detailed Proposal] – Story Points = 28 (Effort 13.5, Complexity 4.5, Uncertainty 10) + AIR
 +
:* B. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NXa8jq6DthJyF8b1uCUmBGVwuPaZGkGbW-DtVAXYsEI/edit?usp=sharing Contrast Administration Management - Detailed Proposal] – Story Points = 8 (Effort 6, Complexity 2, Uncertainty 0) +2 for new editor
 +
:* C. [[AI Results - Brief Proposal]] – Story Points = 13 (Effort 8, Complexity 2.5, Uncertainty 2.5)
 +
:* D. ''[[Reject Analysis - Brief Proposal]] - Withdrawn''
 +
:* E. [[RAD TF Maintenance 2019-2020]] – 35%
  
−
'''Update''': We piloted a refinement of the '''[[Proposal Effort Evaluation]]''' process this year.
+
For comparison, last years estimates are here:
 +
:* B. [[Import_and_Display_of_External_Priors-_Proposal]]
 +
:* A. [[Encounter Based Imaging Workflow for Lightweight Devices - Proposal]]
 +
:* C. [[Follow-up of Non Critical Actionable Findings - Proposal]]
 +
:* D. [[Contrast Administration Monitoring - Brief Proposal]]
 +
:* E. [[Respiratory Correlated Imaging - Brief Proposal]]
  
−
:* A. [[Encounter Based Imaging Workflow for Lightweight Devices - Proposal]] =========> 30% / 20% (SP 18.5 / 10)
+
===Short List/ Detailed Proposals===
−
:* B. [[Import_and_Display_of_External_Priors-_Proposal]] ========================> 40% / 25% (SP 27 / 16)
+
The Tech Cmte agreed to evaluate 6 proposals.  The following Proposals were shortlisted by the [[Rad Plan Minutes 2019-08-23| Planning Committee on Aug 23, 2019]].
−
:* C. [[Follow-up of Non Critical Actionable Findings - Proposal]] ====================> 45% / 30% (SP 31 / 19)
 
−
:* D. [[Contrast Administration Monitoring - Brief Proposal]] ========================> 25% ( SP 14 / 13)
 
−
:* E. [[Respiratory Correlated Imaging - Brief Proposal]] ===========================> 20%  ( SP 11)
 
−
:* F. [[Image Based AI Workflow - Detailed Proposal]] - Withdrawn
 
−
:* G. [[Maintenance of Radiology Profiles Published in 2018 and earlier - Brief Proposal]] => 30-35%
 
  
 +
:* A. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1OSYGW0J5YC7wRIkNzWJSCz-VVmtQIu4WGF5gSUF3XsE/edit?usp=sharing Image Based AI Workflow - Detailed Proposal]
 +
:* B. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NXa8jq6DthJyF8b1uCUmBGVwuPaZGkGbW-DtVAXYsEI/edit?usp=sharing Contrast Administration Management - Detailed Proposal]
 +
:* C. [[AI Results - Brief Proposal]]
 +
:* D. [[Reject Analysis - Brief Proposal]] - Withdrawn
 +
:* E. [[RAD TF Maintenance 2019-2020]]
  
−
'''Reviewers''':  Please enter your comments under Risks and Open Issues section of the proposal by COB Sept 5, 2018
 
  
−
'''Editors''': To convert your Brief Proposal to a Detailed Proposal:
+
'''Editors''': To convert your Brief Proposal to a Detailed Proposal by COB Sept 6, 2019:
 
* Copy the [[Delta Proposal Template]] into the bottom of your proposal page
 
* Copy the [[Delta Proposal Template]] into the bottom of your proposal page
−
* Update as described in the Delta Template (adds Summary, Technical Details, Evaluation etc.)
+
* Update as described in the Delta Template (adds Summary, Technical Details, Evaluation, Breakdown of Tasks, etc.)
 
* Your goal is to give sufficient detail for the Tech Cmte to be able to evaluate the technical feasibility, specification tasks and effort required.
 
* Your goal is to give sufficient detail for the Tech Cmte to be able to evaluate the technical feasibility, specification tasks and effort required.
  
−
Tech Cmte evaluations will be recorded at the bottom of each detailed proposal.
+
'''Reviewers''':  Feel free to enter comments under Risks and Open Issues section of the proposal
−
-->
+
 
 +
Tech Cmte evaluations will be recorded at the bottom of each detailed proposal including the "Breakdown of Tasks" and "Story Point" refinements to the '''[[Proposal Effort Evaluation]]''' process used in recent years.
  
 
===Brief Proposals===
 
===Brief Proposals===
  
−
The following X Proposals were submitted by the August 16, 2019, midnight deadline.   
+
The following five Proposals were submitted by the August 16, 2019, midnight deadline.   
−
 
 
−
:* A.
 
−
 
 
−
===Call for Proposals===
 
−
Interested parties are invited to submit proposal pages based on the '''[[Brief Proposal Template]]'''.
 
  
−
You are also welcome to update and resubmit proposals from '''[[Radiology Proposals 2018-2019|last year]]''' or earlier.
+
:* A. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1OSYGW0J5YC7wRIkNzWJSCz-VVmtQIu4WGF5gSUF3XsE/edit?usp=sharing Image Based AI Workflow - Detailed Proposal]
 +
:* B. [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NXa8jq6DthJyF8b1uCUmBGVwuPaZGkGbW-DtVAXYsEI/edit?usp=sharing Contrast Administration Management - Detailed Proposal]
 +
:* C. [[AI Results - Brief Proposal]]
 +
:* D. [[Reject Analysis - Brief Proposal]]
 +
:* E. [[RAD TF Maintenance 2019-2020]] - contents need to be updated
  
 
===Call for Proposals===
 
===Call for Proposals===
Line 55: Line 61:
  
 
You are also welcome to update and resubmit proposals from '''[[Radiology Proposals 2018-2019|last year]]''' or earlier.
 
You are also welcome to update and resubmit proposals from '''[[Radiology Proposals 2018-2019|last year]]''' or earlier.
−
 
−
1. Enter the name of your proposal (e.g. Management of Fantastic Notions - Brief Proposal) and click the Create button.
 
−
 
−
<createbox>
 
−
type=create
 
−
buttonlabel=Create New Proposal
 
−
preload=Brief Proposal Template
 
−
editintro=Brief Proposal Instructions
 
−
align=left
 
−
width=45
 
−
break=no
 
−
</createbox>
 
−
 
−
2. Finish editing your new page, then edit '''this''' page (see the edit button up at the top) to add a link to your new page to the Brief Proposal list above.
 
−
 
  
 
Contact radiology@ihe.net with any questions.
 
Contact radiology@ihe.net with any questions.

Latest revision as of 16:56, 12 November 2019

Final Selection

Final selection by the Planning Committee on Sept 25, 2019 totaled 105% for development work in this cycle.

  • Maintenance (35%)
  • AI Results (25%)
  • AI Workflow (45% = 70%-25% for results)

Candidates:

Effort Evaluations

The Technical Committee evaluated the required effort of the Detailed Proposals as follows in tcons on Sept 12, 13 & 16.

For comparison, last years estimates are here:

Short List/ Detailed Proposals

The Tech Cmte agreed to evaluate 6 proposals. The following Proposals were shortlisted by the Planning Committee on Aug 23, 2019.


Editors: To convert your Brief Proposal to a Detailed Proposal by COB Sept 6, 2019:

  • Copy the Delta Proposal Template into the bottom of your proposal page
  • Update as described in the Delta Template (adds Summary, Technical Details, Evaluation, Breakdown of Tasks, etc.)
  • Your goal is to give sufficient detail for the Tech Cmte to be able to evaluate the technical feasibility, specification tasks and effort required.

Reviewers: Feel free to enter comments under Risks and Open Issues section of the proposal

Tech Cmte evaluations will be recorded at the bottom of each detailed proposal including the "Breakdown of Tasks" and "Story Point" refinements to the Proposal Effort Evaluation process used in recent years.

Brief Proposals

The following five Proposals were submitted by the August 16, 2019, midnight deadline.

Call for Proposals

Interested parties are invited to submit proposal pages based on the Brief Proposal Template.

You are also welcome to update and resubmit proposals from last year or earlier.

Contact radiology@ihe.net with any questions.

Committee Links

Radiology Planning Committee

Radiology Technical Committee

Retrieved from "http://wiki.ihe.net/index.php?title=Radiology_Proposals_2019-2020&oldid=118575"