Difference between revisions of "PCD Cochairs 2008-11-13 Webex"

From IHE Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(13 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 9: Line 9:
 
== Proposed Agenda ==  
 
== Proposed Agenda ==  
 
: Minutes of November 6, 2008
 
: Minutes of November 6, 2008
 +
: Review PCD Governance Wiki
 +
::- Voting on Minutes (various options), acceptance of Discussion Summaries
 +
::- Can we implement this in the PC, TC (which has several Summaries outstanding)?
 +
: PCD PC & TC Roster Pages
 +
: Review [[IHE_PCD_Google_Groups | Google Groups wiki list]]
 +
: Update on Connectathon / Showcase Activities
 +
: Cycle 4 Proposals Update
 
: Action Items
 
: Action Items
 
: IHE International (IP, quorum, elections)
 
: IHE International (IP, quorum, elections)
:  
+
: IHE Marketing (WSJ Continua article)
 +
: Planning for 2009-2010 budget
 +
: Meeting schedule (no meeting Nov 27, Dec 25, Jan 1) should any be added?
 
: Other
 
: Other
  
 
== Attachments / Materials ==
 
== Attachments / Materials ==
'''placeholder'''
 
: ''Minutes of earlier meetings'' October 2, 9, 16: [[PCD Cochairs 2008-10-02 Webex]], [[PCD Cochairs 2008-10-09 Webex]], [[PCD Cochairs 2008-10-16 Webex]]
 
  
 +
: ''Discussion Summary of earlier meetings'' November 6: [[PCD Cochairs 2008-11-06 Webex]]
 
'' Action Items Brought Forward ''
 
'' Action Items Brought Forward ''
  
Line 43: Line 51:
 
| align="center" | 55
 
| align="center" | 55
 
| '''<Action Item>''' | Showcase vendor display policy
 
| '''<Action Item>''' | Showcase vendor display policy
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Todd
+
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Steve Merritt
 
| '''<Participants>''' | Ray, Elliot
 
| '''<Participants>''' | Ray, Elliot
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 10/21/08
+
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 12/3/08
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
| '''<Comments>:'''  | Will include in draft Domain Governance document. Would be best to have in place by the F2F; add to PC agenda. Todd will develop a Wiki page for discussion, and a vote at the F2F. Also see #57.  
+
| '''<Comments>:'''  | Will include in draft Domain Governance document. Was not discussed last week. Issues may exist with third party devices brought by Cerner and Capsule this year. Waiting for Chris Carr, Didi to provide direction on bi-directional distributed demo. Also see #57.  
  
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | 57
 
| align="center" | 57
 
| '''<Action Item>''' | Develop PCD governance document.
 
| '''<Action Item>''' | Develop PCD governance document.
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Ray
+
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Ken
 
| '''<Participants>''' | Cochairs
 
| '''<Participants>''' | Cochairs
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 10/21/08
+
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 11/20/08
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
| '''<Comments>:'''  | Supplements the IHE governance document (e.g., quorum and non-quorum meetings). See #63, 64. Ray will review ITI document and modify for PCD. Add to F2F agenda for joint PC/TC portion.
+
| '''<Comments>:'''  | Supplements the IHE governance document (e.g., quorum and non-quorum meetings). See #63, 64 also. Ken developed a draft sent for review to Didi. Will go to a PC and TC vote.
 
+
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | 61
 
| align="center" | 61
Line 65: Line 73:
 
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 10/21/08
 
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 10/21/08
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
| '''<Comments>:'''  | Survey closed some time ago. Ray was asked if any results will be available at the F2F. Add to F2F agenda.
+
| '''<Comments>:'''  | Survey closed. Post to ftp site and post links on Planning Committee pages.
 
 
|-
 
| align="center" | 62
 
| '''<Action Item>''' | Add Governance page to IHE PCD Wiki
 
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Todd
 
| '''<Participants>''' |
 
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 10/16/08
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 
| '''<Comments>:'''  | See #57, ITI as an exemplar; Todd will post before F2F.  
 
  
 
|-
 
|-
Line 83: Line 82:
 
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 10/21/08
 
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 10/21/08
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
| '''<Comments>:'''  | Add Quorum issues to Ray's discussion IP with Didi. Ray will incorporate in Governance and submit to IHE. Also see #57, 64. Add to F2F.
+
| '''<Comments>:'''  | Didi addressed some of the questions at the F2F. Add Quorum issues to Ray's discussion IP with Didi. Ray will incorporate in Governance and submit to IHE. Also see #57, 64. Add to F2F.
 
 
|-
 
| align="center" | 64
 
| '''<Action Item>''' | IP and patent issues - risks to IHE
 
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Todd
 
| '''<Participants>''' |
 
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 10/21/08
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 
| '''<Comments>:'''  | What if WG on a Profile runs into an IP or patent issue? Ray will incorporate in Governance and submit to IHE. Also see #57, 63. Add to F2F for discussion with Didi.
 
  
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | 70
 
| align="center" | 70
 
| '''<Action Item>''' | IEEE MOU
 
| '''<Action Item>''' | IEEE MOU
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Ray
+
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Todd
| '''<Participants>''' |  
+
| '''<Participants>''' | Elliot
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 9/18/08
+
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 11/2008
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
| '''<Comments>:'''  | Concern on two issues: use of IEEE intellectual property, need to establish mechanism to continue and maintain the RTM effort. Todd was to ask IEEE for update.
+
| '''<Comments>:'''  | Concern on two issues: use of IEEE intellectual property, need to establish mechanism to continue and maintain the RTM effort. Todd was to ask IEEE for update. Manny to contact Didi with request that she be sure it is on the IHE Board agenda for Dec. 13th.  
  
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | 74
 
| align="center" | 74
 
| '''<Action Item>''' | Clinical Recruitment
 
| '''<Action Item>''' | Clinical Recruitment
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Ray
+
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Steve
 
| '''<Participants>''' | Cochairs and PC  
 
| '''<Participants>''' | Cochairs and PC  
 
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 2008.08.28
 
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 2008.08.28
Line 117: Line 107:
 
:* (Zambuto/Furst) Ray will contact Rick Schrenker re F2F participation. Dr. Mun may attend F2F.
 
:* (Zambuto/Furst) Ray will contact Rick Schrenker re F2F participation. Dr. Mun may attend F2F.
 
:* (Cooper) To contact Rick Schrenker re. profile proposal review.
 
:* (Cooper) To contact Rick Schrenker re. profile proposal review.
 
+
:* Manny discussed PCD's proposal for a presentation while PCD members are in Chicago for the Connectathon, or afterward, with Lisa who is supportive.
|-
 
| align="center" | 76
 
| '''<Action Item>''' | Cochairs Election Preparation
 
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Ray
 
| '''<Participants>''' | Ray, Manny
 
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 9/18/08
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 
| '''<Comments>:'''  | Ray will contact three potential PC cochairs and two potential TC cochairs.  
 
  
 
|-
 
|-
Line 131: Line 113:
 
| '''<Action Item>''' | Monitor HITSP development of RMON and coordinate a demonstration with HITSP.  
 
| '''<Action Item>''' | Monitor HITSP development of RMON and coordinate a demonstration with HITSP.  
 
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Todd
 
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Todd
| '''<Participants>''' |  
+
| '''<Participants>''' | Paul
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 10/30/08
+
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 12/3/08
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 
| '''<Comments>:'''  |  Todd will monitor and coordinate with HITSP, including response to public comment period, due Oct. 24.
 
| '''<Comments>:'''  |  Todd will monitor and coordinate with HITSP, including response to public comment period, due Oct. 24.
Line 138: Line 120:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | 78
 
| align="center" | 78
| '''<Action Item>''' | Foster collaboration with Continua and monitor developments. Coordinate with Didi, Joyce. Sept. 17
+
| '''<Action Item>''' | Foster collaboration with Continua and monitor developments. Coordinate with Didi, Joyce. N
 
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Todd
 
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Todd
 
| '''<Participants>''' | Paul
 
| '''<Participants>''' | Paul
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 9/18/08
+
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 12/3/08
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
| '''<Comments>:'''  |  Paul will do what he can to act as a point of contact to foster communication between PCD and Continua.  
+
| '''<Comments>:'''  |  Paul will act as a point of contact to foster communication between PCD and Continua. Coordinate with Didi.
HITSP, Continua and PCD were represented on a conference call earlier, with no agreement on how to encode and send the messages. While RTM appears agreeable for coding parameters and units of measure, Continua does not want to use PCD-01, which was the placeholder construct at an RMON meeting in Chicago. Continua may submit an alternative.
 
 
 
The MOU between IHE and Continua may permit a limited, low cost membership permitting PCD representation at meetings. Another approach is to start with Rosetta. As for joint demonstrations, that may be more difficult since Continua has held several “plug fests” and has the resources to proceed independently, but this may be possible.
 
 
   
 
   
  
Line 158: Line 137:
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 
| '''<Comments>:'''  | To enable coordinating profiles, similar to the Continua document. Ken will open discussion with Julian re the MOU, develop draft. Will discuss at CIMIT Oct. 24 (see #26).
 
| '''<Comments>:'''  | To enable coordinating profiles, similar to the Continua document. Ken will open discussion with Julian re the MOU, develop draft. Will discuss at CIMIT Oct. 24 (see #26).
 +
 +
|-
 +
| align="center" | 80
 +
| '''<Action Item>''' | Review meeting dates
 +
 +
| '''<Owner>:'''  | Manny
 +
| '''<Participants>''' |
 +
| '''<Due Date>'''  | 11/20/08
 +
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 +
| '''<Comments>:'''  | Manny to contact election winners and conduct a survey on available times for cochairs meetings. In addition to setting dates/times with new cochairs, cochairs should consider three meetings will fall on holidays in the short term.
 +
 +
|-
 +
| align="center" |
 +
| '''<Action Item>''' |
 +
 +
| '''<Owner>:'''  |
 +
| '''<Participants>''' |
 +
| '''<Due Date>'''  |
 +
| '''<Status>''' | OPEN
 +
| '''<Comments>:'''  |
  
  
Line 169: Line 168:
 
=== Participants ===
 
=== Participants ===
  
:  
+
: Todd Cooper, Ken Fuchs, Ray Zambuto, Manny Furst
  
 
=== Discussion ===  
 
=== Discussion ===  
: ''<Adjust table rows per meeting needs>''
+
 
 
:{|border="2"  
 
:{|border="2"  
 
|-
 
|-
Line 183: Line 182:
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
 +
:* Approved
 +
'''Action(s):'''
  
'''Action(s):'''
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | 2
 
| align="center" | 2
| '''Approval of Minutes''' <br>- Chair
+
| '''Approval of Minutes''' <br>- Todd
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
 +
:* Minutes of November 6 were approved.
 +
'''Action(s):'''
  
'''Action(s):'''
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | 3
 
| align="center" | 3
| '''Action Items Review''' <br>- Chair
+
| '''Action Items''' <br>- Ken
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
:* ...
+
Only one item on the list was addressed:
 +
:* #57: Ken led discussion of the draft. Following discussion items noted here, the cochairs approved the draft and requested Didi review and comment before it is submitted to the PCD PC and TC.
 +
:: • Quorum for cochairs would be three members, including non-voting members.
 +
:: • Decisions require a minimum of two cochairs.
 +
:: • A vote carries with 66% affirmative of those voting.
 +
:: • Distinctions between WGs and TGs: WGs create documents for IHE, TG may initiate documents, but they contribute that to a WG or Committee.
 +
:: • Email ballots will close a minimum of two weeks from distribution.
 +
:: • Have Didi review the Wiki page, with special attention to Proxy and to Board Representative Election sections.
 +
:: Todd asked about maintenance of the PC and TC roster pages and the voting eligibility it provides. Manny is responsible to provide the IHE Coordinator (Celina Roth) with company names when votes are taken and F2F meetings attended, and she is responsible for maintaining the Wiki page.
 +
 
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
:*
 
  
 
'''Action(s):'''
 
'''Action(s):'''
:*  
+
:* Manny to request Didi's review of the draft.
 +
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | 4
 
| align="center" | 4
| '''xyz''' <br>- <lead>
+
| '''Nomination for Emeritus Seat''' <br>- Ray
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
:* ...
+
:* Jack Harrington will apply for ACCE membership and PCD will nominate him for one of the four seats.
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
:*
 
  
 
'''Action(s):'''
 
'''Action(s):'''
:*
 
  
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | 5
 
| align="center" | 5
| '''xyz''' <br>- <lead>
+
| '''PCD Google Groups Wiki Page''' <br>- Todd
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
 
:* ...
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
 
:*
 
 
 
'''Action(s):'''
 
:*
 
 
 
|-
 
| align="center" | 6
 
| '''xyz''' <br>- <lead>
 
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
:* ...
+
:* John Rhoads provided an index to PCD Google Groups at http://wiki.ihe.net/index.php?title=IHE_PCD_Google_Groups
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
 
:*
 
  
'''Action(s):'''
 
:*
 
 
|-
 
| align="center" | 7
 
| '''xyz''' <br>- <lead>
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
 
:* ...
 
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
:*
 
  
 
'''Action(s):'''
 
'''Action(s):'''
:*  
+
:* Manny to add explanatory material to Connectathon GGs and others as needed. He will also check for completeness.
  
|-
 
| align="center" | 8
 
| '''xyz''' <br>- <lead>
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
 
:* ...
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
 
:*
 
 
'''Action(s):'''
 
:*
 
  
 
|-
 
|-
| align="center" | 9
+
| align="center" | 6
| '''xyz''' <br>- <lead>
+
| '''Meeting Schedule''' <br>- Manny
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
:* ...
+
:* Three upcoming cochairs meetings fall on holidays.
 +
:* Steve Merritt has a conflict with the time of the Cochairs meeting and is attempting to manage this.
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
:*
 
  
 
'''Action(s):'''
 
'''Action(s):'''
:*  
+
:* Manny to contact election winners and conduct a survey on available times for cochairs meetings.
  
|-
 
| align="center" | n
 
| '''Next Meeting''' <br>- Chair
 
| '''Status/Discussion:'''
 
'''Decisions/Issues:'''
 
  
'''Action(s):'''
 
 
|}
 
|}
 
  
 
=== Next Meeting ===
 
=== Next Meeting ===
''The next meeting will be November 20: [[PCD Cochairs 2008-11-13 Webex]]''
+
''The next meeting will be November 20: [[PCD Cochairs 2008-11-20 Webex]]''
  
  
Line 286: Line 255:
  
 
[[Patient Care Device | PCD Home]]
 
[[Patient Care Device | PCD Home]]
[[Category:PCD Meeting]]
+
[[Category:PCD Meeting Archive]]

Latest revision as of 12:36, 24 January 2009

Patient Care Device Cochairs Weekly Meeting

Date: Thursday, November 13, 2008

Time: 3:00 pm, Eastern Time

Duration: 60 Minutes

Proposed Agenda

Minutes of November 6, 2008
Review PCD Governance Wiki
- Voting on Minutes (various options), acceptance of Discussion Summaries
- Can we implement this in the PC, TC (which has several Summaries outstanding)?
PCD PC & TC Roster Pages
Review Google Groups wiki list
Update on Connectathon / Showcase Activities
Cycle 4 Proposals Update
Action Items
IHE International (IP, quorum, elections)
IHE Marketing (WSJ Continua article)
Planning for 2009-2010 budget
Meeting schedule (no meeting Nov 27, Dec 25, Jan 1) should any be added?
Other

Attachments / Materials

Discussion Summary of earlier meetings November 6: PCD Cochairs 2008-11-06 Webex

Action Items Brought Forward

Number Action Owner Participants Due Date Status Comments


26 Open discussions on unifying efforts for device interoperability - facility for year 'round lab Ray Ken 10/23/08 OPEN Julian will be asked to attend the DPI meeting Friday, Oct. 24 at CIMIT. Nothing yet to report about developing a test lab. A new Action Item, #79, for PCD to develop the MOU that is intended to enable coordinating profiles, similar to the Continua document. Ken will open discussion with Julian re the MOU.
55 Showcase vendor display policy Steve Merritt Ray, Elliot 12/3/08 OPEN Will include in draft Domain Governance document. Was not discussed last week. Issues may exist with third party devices brought by Cerner and Capsule this year. Waiting for Chris Carr, Didi to provide direction on bi-directional distributed demo. Also see #57.
57 Develop PCD governance document. Ken Cochairs 11/20/08 OPEN Supplements the IHE governance document (e.g., quorum and non-quorum meetings). See #63, 64 also. Ken developed a draft sent for review to Didi. Will go to a PC and TC vote.
61 Analyze, publish results of survey Ray 10/21/08 OPEN Survey closed. Post to ftp site and post links on Planning Committee pages.
63 IHE Governance: IP, participation in F2F, etc. Cochairs 10/21/08 OPEN Didi addressed some of the questions at the F2F. Add Quorum issues to Ray's discussion IP with Didi. Ray will incorporate in Governance and submit to IHE. Also see #57, 64. Add to F2F.
70 IEEE MOU Todd Elliot 11/2008 OPEN Concern on two issues: use of IEEE intellectual property, need to establish mechanism to continue and maintain the RTM effort. Todd was to ask IEEE for update. Manny to contact Didi with request that she be sure it is on the IHE Board agenda for Dec. 13th.
74 Clinical Recruitment Steve Cochairs and PC 2008.08.28 OPEN
  • (Zambuto) Review IHE membership to identify recruitment opportunities.
  • (All) Identify invitation opportunities for participation in the October F2F.
  • (Cooper)Update profiles wiki page so as to capture the attention of clinical reviewers.
  • (Zambuto) Ask Mario Castenada re. KP participants (perhaps also Michael Robkin)
  • (Zambuto/Furst) Ray will contact Rick Schrenker re F2F participation. Dr. Mun may attend F2F.
  • (Cooper) To contact Rick Schrenker re. profile proposal review.
  • Manny discussed PCD's proposal for a presentation while PCD members are in Chicago for the Connectathon, or afterward, with Lisa who is supportive.
77 Monitor HITSP development of RMON and coordinate a demonstration with HITSP. Todd Paul 12/3/08 OPEN Todd will monitor and coordinate with HITSP, including response to public comment period, due Oct. 24.
78 Foster collaboration with Continua and monitor developments. Coordinate with Didi, Joyce. N Todd Paul 12/3/08 OPEN Paul will act as a point of contact to foster communication between PCD and Continua. Coordinate with Didi.


79 PCD to develop the MOU with Julian. Ken 10/24/08 OPEN To enable coordinating profiles, similar to the Continua document. Ken will open discussion with Julian re the MOU, develop draft. Will discuss at CIMIT Oct. 24 (see #26).
80 Review meeting dates Manny 11/20/08 OPEN Manny to contact election winners and conduct a survey on available times for cochairs meetings. In addition to setting dates/times with new cochairs, cochairs should consider three meetings will fall on holidays in the short term.
OPEN


Minutes

Participants

Todd Cooper, Ken Fuchs, Ray Zambuto, Manny Furst

Discussion

Item Topic Discussion
1 Introductions & Agenda Review
- Chair
Status/Discussion:

Decisions/Issues:

  • Approved

Action(s):

2 Approval of Minutes
- Todd
Status/Discussion:

Decisions/Issues:

  • Minutes of November 6 were approved.

Action(s):

3 Action Items
- Ken
Status/Discussion:

Only one item on the list was addressed:

  • #57: Ken led discussion of the draft. Following discussion items noted here, the cochairs approved the draft and requested Didi review and comment before it is submitted to the PCD PC and TC.
• Quorum for cochairs would be three members, including non-voting members.
• Decisions require a minimum of two cochairs.
• A vote carries with 66% affirmative of those voting.
• Distinctions between WGs and TGs: WGs create documents for IHE, TG may initiate documents, but they contribute that to a WG or Committee.
• Email ballots will close a minimum of two weeks from distribution.
• Have Didi review the Wiki page, with special attention to Proxy and to Board Representative Election sections.
Todd asked about maintenance of the PC and TC roster pages and the voting eligibility it provides. Manny is responsible to provide the IHE Coordinator (Celina Roth) with company names when votes are taken and F2F meetings attended, and she is responsible for maintaining the Wiki page.

Decisions/Issues:

Action(s):

  • Manny to request Didi's review of the draft.
4 Nomination for Emeritus Seat
- Ray
Status/Discussion:
  • Jack Harrington will apply for ACCE membership and PCD will nominate him for one of the four seats.

Decisions/Issues:

Action(s):

5 PCD Google Groups Wiki Page
- Todd
Status/Discussion:

Decisions/Issues:

Action(s):

  • Manny to add explanatory material to Connectathon GGs and others as needed. He will also check for completeness.


6 Meeting Schedule
- Manny
Status/Discussion:
  • Three upcoming cochairs meetings fall on holidays.
  • Steve Merritt has a conflict with the time of the Cochairs meeting and is attempting to manage this.

Decisions/Issues:

Action(s):

  • Manny to contact election winners and conduct a survey on available times for cochairs meetings.


Next Meeting

The next meeting will be November 20: PCD Cochairs 2008-11-20 Webex


<Add review line here when minutes are approved; e.g., "(Reviewed & approved by PCD RTM Vent TG 2008-04-16)">


PCD Home