Difference between revisions of "ITI Planning Committee 2012/2013 Meetings"

From IHE Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 196: Line 196:
 
:*Capacity of ITI for new profile/white paper proposals (decision)
 
:*Capacity of ITI for new profile/white paper proposals (decision)
 
| ITI co-chairs
 
| ITI co-chairs
|
+
| Discussion of capacity not conclusive.  Roughly 2 new supplements and 3 white papers, 5 work items total.
 
|-
 
|-
 
|  9:30-10:00 CT
 
|  9:30-10:00 CT
Line 213: Line 213:
 
:*** Prior year used three ballots per organization for 5 proposals
 
:*** Prior year used three ballots per organization for 5 proposals
 
| ITI Planning co-chairs
 
| ITI Planning co-chairs
|
+
|  
 +
* suggestion of reviewing the stragetic plan for the last two alignment criteria
 +
* minor wording improvements to degree of adoption
 +
* consideration of other domain requests, is the column in criteria enough?  re-assess at end of day
 +
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| 10:00-10:45 CT
 
| 10:00-10:45 CT
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 2.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/IHE_Profile_Proposal_Template-Brief-DSUBb.docx DSUB.b]
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 2.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/IHE_Profile_Proposal_Template-Brief-DSUBb.docx DSUB.b]
 
| Mauro  Zanardini
 
| Mauro  Zanardini
|
+
| [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/ITI-Profile-Proposal-FSPN-Planning-10_Oct.ppt Presentation]
 +
* concern that there are two requests lumped together making it hard to evaluate
 +
* concern that the use case is not presented, only a solution is presented and cannot assess the value
 +
* technical discussion of solution status
 +
* break into two proposals
 +
# full metadata subsciption
 +
# pull-style notification
 
|-
 
|-
 
| 10:45-11:00 CT
 
| 10:45-11:00 CT
Line 228: Line 238:
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 1.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/IHE%20ITI-2012-Brief-Proposal-OAuth.02.doc OAuth option for mHealth]
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 1.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/IHE%20ITI-2012-Brief-Proposal-OAuth.02.doc OAuth option for mHealth]
 
| Rob Horn
 
| Rob Horn
|
+
| [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/ITI-Brief-OAuth.03.ppt Presentation]
 +
* will be structured as a profile that becomes an optional grouping with MHD
 +
* concern with external visibility of support for mobile - defered to general discussions outside of this proposal
 
|-
 
|-
 
| 11:30-12:00 CT
 
| 11:30-12:00 CT
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 4.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/XDW%20with%20XCA%20Proposal.docx Extend XDW to XCA]
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 4.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/XDW%20with%20XCA%20Proposal.docx Extend XDW to XCA]
 
| Charles Parisot
 
| Charles Parisot
|
+
| [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/XDW%20with%20XCA%20Proposal-V2.docx Presentation]
 +
* size is medium
 +
* unclear resources, consider charles as editor for now
 +
* technical discussion, perhaps use XDR, challenge of use of folders
 
|-
 
|-
 
| 12:00-12:30 CT
 
| 12:00-12:30 CT
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 5.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/Findings-notification-ITI-2013.doc Findings Notification]
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 5.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/Findings-notification-ITI-2013.doc Findings Notification]
 
| Mike Henderson/Rob Horn
 
| Mike Henderson/Rob Horn
|
+
| [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/ITI-Findings-notification-2013.04.ppt Presentation]
 +
* agreed that this moves forward to ITI Tech without further discussion in this group
 
|-
 
|-
 
| 12:30-1:30 CT
 
| 12:30-1:30 CT
Line 248: Line 264:
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 3.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/12-10-05%20IHE%20ILR%20Profile%20Proposal%20v3.docx Interlinked Registries (ILR)]
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 3.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/12-10-05%20IHE%20ILR%20Profile%20Proposal%20v3.docx Interlinked Registries (ILR)]
 
| Ron Parker
 
| Ron Parker
|
+
| [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/12-10-28%20draft%20interlinked%20registries%20project%20scope%20v2.pptx Presentation]
 +
* discussion of constraints and architecture
 
|-
 
|-
 
|  2:30-3:00 CT
 
|  2:30-3:00 CT
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 7.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/IHE%20ITI-2012-Brief-Proposal-Pseudonymization-Paper-v001.doc Pseudonymization]
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 7.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/IHE%20ITI-2012-Brief-Proposal-Pseudonymization-Paper-v001.doc Pseudonymization]
 
| Eric Heflin
 
| Eric Heflin
|
+
| Reviewed plan and current status.  Agreed to pass to ITI Tech without further discussion in Planning.
 
|-
 
|-
 
|  3:00-3:30 CT
 
|  3:00-3:30 CT
Line 263: Line 280:
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 6.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/IHE%20ITI-2012-Breif-Proposal-DS-redoc-01.doc Document Sharing redocumentation]
 
| '''Advocacy''' - ITI 6.0 [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/iheitiyr11-2013-2014/Planning_Cmte/BriefProfileProposals/IHE%20ITI-2012-Breif-Proposal-DS-redoc-01.doc Document Sharing redocumentation]
 
| Karen Witting
 
| Karen Witting
|
+
| Discussed approaches to broaden participation. Agreed to pass to ITI Tech without further discussion in Planning.
 
|-
 
|-
 
|  4:00-5:00 CT
 
|  4:00-5:00 CT
Line 276: Line 293:
 
:*Conclude Process used to develop a prioritized work item list
 
:*Conclude Process used to develop a prioritized work item list
 
|  
 
|  
|
+
| Began filling out criteria spreadsheet.  Concern with interlinked registries, felt there was a lack of understanding of the use case.  Will discuss again in the morning with clarification from submittors.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| 5:00 pm CT
 
| 5:00 pm CT

Revision as of 11:41, 6 November 2012

Introduction

This WIKI page documents the activities of the ITI Planning Committee during the 2012/2013 committee year (August 2012 - July 2013). These activities include:

  • Call for Proposals : August-October
  • Review and selection of Proposals : October-December
  • Updates/Additions to Educational Materials/White Papers/Etc. : December-July

Important Dates

Date Event Comments
5-Oct-2012

11:59pm CDT

Call for Proposals CLOSE Submitted proposals can be found here.
10-Oct-2012 Webinar 1 - 9:00am-11:00 CDT Details
12-Oct-2012 Webinar 2 - 9:00am-11:00 CDT CANCELLED
16-Oct-2012 Webinar 3 - 9:00am-11:00 CDT CANCELLED
30-Oct-2012 - 31-Oct-2012 ITI Planning Committee f2f Details

Webinar Organization

Each webinar will be organized as follows (this will vary slightly depending upon how many proposals we will be reviewing:

  • The two hour time allocation will be divided into 20-minute time-slots, with the remaining time for introductory remarks and follow-up discussion.
  • Each 20-minute timeslot will be allocated to a profile/white paper proposal… the first 10 minutes will be taken up by a presentation by the proposal author, with the remaining 10 minutes reserved for discussion and any disposition (if required).
  • Each 10-minute presentation will be comprised of a maximum of 5 Powerpoint slides, presenting the proposal concisely and completely.

Webinar 1

Date Time Coordinates Recording of the meeting
10-Oct-2012 9:00-11:00 CDT Join Webex(password "meeting")
1-866-469-3239
925 996 558#
Webinar Recording
Time # Proposal Author/Presenter Comments
9:00-9:10 Webinar Introduction, process Karen Witting, Claudio Saccavini : co-Chairs
9:10-9:30 ITI 3.0 Interlinked Registries (ILR) Derek Ritz Presentation Concern raised that this proposal will require careful scoping and understanding of available resources in order to ensure success in the one year timeframe. Understanding of requirements priorities will help this scoping.
9:30-9:50 ITI 1.0 OAuth option for mHealth Rob Horn Presentation Discussion of value of use case 1. Need greater understanding of the risks and benefits of using a draft standard. For planning purposes need better understanding of the requirements being addressed.
9:50-10:10 ITI 2.0 DSUB.b Mauro Zanardini Presentation Two parts of the request, first part simple extension to DSUB, second part more complicated "create a system of notification that is managed by access control policies", like BPPC associated with a subscription. Consider NAV profile. Look for overlap with other notification systems.
10:10-10:30 ITI 4.0 Extend XDW to XCA Charles Parisot Policy landscape will need to be expanded to allow for this. May consider XDR as part of the solution.
10:30-10:50 ITI 5.0

ITI 6.0

ITI 7.0

  • Rob Horn
  • Karen Witting
  • Eric Heflin
  • Findings Notification - have an architectural statement and thinking to write a draft profile and see if this helps reconcile the issues. White paper is "roaming around" but not officially published for feedback. Planning to publish in December timeframe.
  • DS* redocumentation - have completed high level model section. Plan for public comment in June or before.
  • Pseudonymization - Defined 9 chapters, first 4 are solid, ready for internal feedback. Next 4 targeted for 2 weeks for internal feedback. Formal review with other domains in november and public review in february.
10:50-11:00 Discussion, Next Steps Karen Witting, Claudio Saccavini : co-Chairs Agreed to use 30-1 hour for each of the new submissions, depending on size. Allow 30 minutes for each continuing work item and request a quick presentation of the work item progress and content.

Webinar 2

Date Time Coordinates Recording of the meeting
12-Oct-2012 9:00-11:00 CDT Join Webex(password "meeting")
1-866-469-3239
927 928 565 #
CANCELED - a single webinar was sufficient

Webinar 3

Date Time Coordinates Recording of the meeting
16-Oct-2012 9:00-11:00 CDT Join Webex(password "meeting")
1-866-469-3239
927 316 058 #
CANCELED - a single webinar was sufficient

F2F Meeting

The following agenda also includes the minutes from the meeting

TUESDAY October 30 - DAY 1

Location Webex/Tcon
RSNA Headquarters
Oak Brook, IL
himss.webex.com
Time Description Presenter Minutes/Notes
9:00-9:15 CT Welcome
  • Introductions
  • Housekeeping
  • Domain Sponsor Announcements
  • Procedures, voting privileges, etc.
  • Agenda review
9:15-9:30 CT ITI Capacity
  • Capacity of ITI for new profile/white paper proposals (decision)
ITI co-chairs Discussion of capacity not conclusive. Roughly 2 new supplements and 3 white papers, 5 work items total.
9:30-10:00 CT Process and evaluation criteria
  • Evaluation Criteria
  • Process used to develop a prioritized work item list
    • Ranking by Criteria
      • Prior year discussed criteria values
    • Ranking by Ballot
      • Prior year used three ballots per organization for 5 proposals
ITI Planning co-chairs
  • suggestion of reviewing the stragetic plan for the last two alignment criteria
  • minor wording improvements to degree of adoption
  • consideration of other domain requests, is the column in criteria enough? re-assess at end of day
10:00-10:45 CT Advocacy - ITI 2.0 DSUB.b Mauro Zanardini Presentation
  • concern that there are two requests lumped together making it hard to evaluate
  • concern that the use case is not presented, only a solution is presented and cannot assess the value
  • technical discussion of solution status
  • break into two proposals
  1. full metadata subsciption
  2. pull-style notification
10:45-11:00 CT Break
11:00-11:30 CT Advocacy - ITI 1.0 OAuth option for mHealth Rob Horn Presentation
  • will be structured as a profile that becomes an optional grouping with MHD
  • concern with external visibility of support for mobile - defered to general discussions outside of this proposal
11:30-12:00 CT Advocacy - ITI 4.0 Extend XDW to XCA Charles Parisot Presentation
  • size is medium
  • unclear resources, consider charles as editor for now
  • technical discussion, perhaps use XDR, challenge of use of folders
12:00-12:30 CT Advocacy - ITI 5.0 Findings Notification Mike Henderson/Rob Horn Presentation
  • agreed that this moves forward to ITI Tech without further discussion in this group
12:30-1:30 CT LUNCH
1:30-2:30 CT Advocacy - ITI 3.0 Interlinked Registries (ILR) Ron Parker Presentation
  • discussion of constraints and architecture
2:30-3:00 CT Advocacy - ITI 7.0 Pseudonymization Eric Heflin Reviewed plan and current status. Agreed to pass to ITI Tech without further discussion in Planning.
3:00-3:30 CT Break
3:30-4:00 CT Advocacy - ITI 6.0 Document Sharing redocumentation Karen Witting Discussed approaches to broaden participation. Agreed to pass to ITI Tech without further discussion in Planning.
4:00-5:00 CT General Discussion and preparation for evaluation ITI Planning co-chairs
  • Continued discussion for work items not fully understood
  • Re-review of Evaluation Criteria
  • Conclude Process used to develop a prioritized work item list
Began filling out criteria spreadsheet. Concern with interlinked registries, felt there was a lack of understanding of the use case. Will discuss again in the morning with clarification from submittors.
5:00 pm CT ADJOURN

WEDNESDAY October 31 - DAY 2

Location Webex/Tcon
RSNA Headquarters
Oak Brook, IL
himss.webex.com
Time Description Minutes/Notes
9:00-9:15 CT Welcome, review of the day's plan
9:15-10:30 CT Discussion and decision on prioritized work item list
  • Complete Ranking by Criteria spreadsheet and review results
  • Ranking by Ballot
  • Decision of prioritized list of proposals
10:30-11:00 CT Break
11:00-11:30 CT Next Steps
  • Assignment of authors, due-dates, etc. for completion of Detailed Proposal (due date TBA) for turn-over to TC in November
11:30-12:30 am CT Marketing and publicity planning
  • Assess status and impact
  • Plan work items for coming year
  • Assess status and work to be done
  • Preparation for meeting at HIMSS
  • Discussion of EU meetings like Wohit
  • Assess other opportunities for communicating about ITI work
12:30-1:30 CT LUNCH
1:30-2:00 CT White Paper Updates
  • Review status and plan next steps
2:00-2:30 CT Connectathon Registration Status
2:30-3:00 CT Strategic planning and liason activities
  • IT Infrastructure Strategy/Categories
  • Review and assess
  • ITI Outreach and liason activity
  • Assess status and planning
3:00 - 3:30 pm CT Wrap-up
  • Schedule followup tcons
  • Assess Trial Implementation profiles movement to Final Text
  • Educational presentations and webinars
  • White Paper Updates
  • Other
3:30 pm CT ADJOURN