Difference between revisions of "ITI CPs 2018-19-Agenda and Minutes from past CP calls"

From IHE Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 16: Line 16:
 
** CP 1094 (ATNA - Add Option:  Require server certificate domain name validation for all traffic over the public internet)
 
** CP 1094 (ATNA - Add Option:  Require server certificate domain name validation for all traffic over the public internet)
 
*** This was discussed and the text was modified based on ballot comments.   
 
*** This was discussed and the text was modified based on ballot comments.   
*** Version -09 contains today's updates.  That version is here:
+
*** Version -09 contains today's updates.  That version is on the ftp site [ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance/CPs/Ballots/2019/Ballot_48/post-ballot-updates/ here].
 
*** Next step:  Vassil will review the updates vs. the ballot comments and identify the issues that remain to be discussed.  Will seek time to finish this in the F2F agenda next week.
 
*** Next step:  Vassil will review the updates vs. the ballot comments and identify the issues that remain to be discussed.  Will seek time to finish this in the F2F agenda next week.
 
**  CP 1124 ( ATNA – Add two options related to BCP195 TLS Secure Transport Connection).   
 
**  CP 1124 ( ATNA – Add two options related to BCP195 TLS Secure Transport Connection).   

Revision as of 11:41, 12 July 2018

ITI domain CPs for 2018-19 are managed here: ITI Change Proposals 2018-19

This page contains the minutes from past CP review calls during the 2018-19 publication cycle.

Current ITI CP status spreadsheet is here

July 12, 2018 - Ballot 48 resolution

Attendees: Angeliki Kritsotaki (Forcare), Gregorio Canal (Arsenal.IT), Elliot Silver (Change Healthcare), Elliott Lavy (N Harris Computer), John Moehrke (ByLight), Ken Meyer (IBM Watson Health), Tarik Idris (InterComponentWare), Vassil Peytchev (Epic), Lynn Felhofer

(1) Resolve 2 ATNA CPs in Ballot 48

(2) Next in CPs

  • No call on July 19 due to the ITI Tech Cmte face-to-face meeting. Appx V CPs will be discussed. See the F2F agenda.

June 28, 2018 - Appx V CPs

Attendees: Elliott Lavy (N Harris Computer), Charles Parisot (GE Healthcare), Jiri Wildbret (Forcare), John Moehrke (ByLight), Vassil Peytchev (Epic), Ben Levy (Corepoint Health), Ken Meyer (IBM Watson Health), Pim van der Eijk, Gregorio Canal (Arsenal.IT), Massimiliano Masi (Tiani-Spirit), Bill Majurski (NIST), Lynn Felhofer

The ITI CP tracking spreadsheet is here.

(1) Prepare Appx V CPs for ballot ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance/CPs/1_Assigned/

CP-ITI-1122 - Redocumentation of Appendix V on SOAP Web Services (Massi)

Next steps --

  1. update CP 1122 based on Lynn's comments (Massi)
  2. create a "clean version of Appendix V" as a standalone document (Massi)
  3. create a draft of CP 1123 (Appx V.3.3 content) (Vassil)
  4. review CP 1123 on July 5 CP call (Charles will chair this)
  5. finish work on these artifacts during the July F2F. Charles will request time on the agenda.

(2) Next in CPs

  • July 5 - Review of CP 1123 (update to Appendix V.3.3 Rqmts for transaction using HL7v3)
  • July 9 - Ballot 48 votes/comments due
  • July 12 - Ballot 48 resolution
  • July 18 - no CP call due to ITI Tech Cmte face-to-face, but time will be requested for Appx V CPs

June 14, 2018

Attendees: Joe Lamy (Aegis//SSA), Elliott Lavy (N Harris Computer), Ken Meyer (IBM Watson Health), John Moehrke (ByLight), Walco van Loon, Angeliki Kriksotaki, Jiri Wildbret (Forcare), Elliot Silver (Change Healthcare), Dave Vaccaro (lifeIMAGE), Lynn Felhofer

The ITI CP tracking spreadsheet is [https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1gdr_Y8xZBvbb326J4z67cqprxOexFgtkPj_VlD3rB9E/edit#gid=0 here'.

(0) Welcome!

Jiri Wilbret and Angeliki Kritsotaki from Forcare joined us. We welcome them as regular participants in upcoming CP calls!

(1) Assigned CPs ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance/CPs/1_Assigned/

Ready to discuss (Forcare):

  • 693 - XDW addAttachment - Forcare staff (Walco, Jiri, Angelika) will formulate a proposal for changes so that the scope can be assessed by ITI Tech at a future CP call. Forcare will seek review from Mauro & Gregorio as changes to the text are written.
  • 697 - PIXv3 Query errors - version -01 approved as Completed for future ballot 49

Get direction on these, or ballot them, or cancel them:

  • 1043-02 - Updates to ITI-18 to enable easier re-use by non-XDS actors (Lynn) - Lynn has proposed text to add a "Consumer" Role to ITI-18, and this CP in its current form shows how this would affect ITI-18 in Vol 2a, and in the XDS-MU and RMD TI Supplements. We discussed the potential benefits and pitfalls of this approach. There is precedent in using the Role construct (eg 'Content Sender' and 'Content Receiver' Roles were introduced in the refactoring of ITI-41 and 42). Next step: Ken volunteered to review the proposed changes to confirm the direction or suggest an alternative. If we proceed with this, the change would be targeted for docs published in 2019.
  • 1051-01 - Align BPPC Vol 1 with convention for Content Profiles & Grouping (Lynn) - discussion deferred to a future call

Propose to cancel (Forcare):

  • 683 - HPD Performance Considerations -- The committee agreed that this can be cancelled. Because Tarik has taken on recent HPD CPs, Lynn will confirm that he has no objection.

(2) Incoming CPs ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance/CPs/0_Incoming/

  • CP-ITI-AlternateUserId-in-ITI-18andITI-51.doc - assigned to David Vaccaro as CP 1129
  • CP-ITI-ESL_U=NotSpecialized.doc - rejected as a de of CP 1058 (to be integrated in 2018)

Out of time for these; deferred to a future call:

  • CP-ITI-JB-ITI-homeCommunityId-audit-fix.doc
  • CP-ITI-NPFSm_Wrong_actor in message semantics.docx
  • CP-ITI-TP-fixXDFinconsistency.doc
  • CP-ITI-DENupdatesToOldVol3.docx

(3) Next in CPs

  • Thu June 21 -- agenda tbd
  • Thu June 28 -- (tentative topic, to be confirmed) prepare Appendix V CPs for ballot (related to AS4 supplement)
  • Thu July 5 -- no CP call due to US Indep day holiday
  • July 9 -- Ballot 48 (ATNA CPs) is out. Votes/comments are due July 9.
  • July 12 -- Resolve Ballot 48 votes/comments
  • July 19 -- no CP call due to ITI Tech F2F meeting this week
  • For August CP calls, Ken proposed focusing on XDS-related CPs. Committee members can work to prepare those for review between now & then.

June 7, 2018

Attendees: Ben Levy (Corepoint Health), Dave Vaccaro (lifeIMAGE), John Moehrke (ByLight), Joe Lamy (Aegis/SSA), Ken Meyer (IBM Watson Health), Rob Horn (SME), Vassil Peytchev (Epic), Gregorio Canal (Arsenal.IT), Tarik Idris (InterComponentWare), Lynn Felhofer

The ITI CP tracking spreadsheet is here.

(1) Revisit ATNA CPs

(2) Incoming CPs ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance/CPs/0_Incoming/

  • CP-ITI-BM-referenceIdList-fix.doc - Assigned to Ken as CP-ITI-1125
  • CP-ITI-BM-ITI-65ReturnBundleRqmts.doc - Assigned to John as CP-ITI-1126
  • CP-ITI-MHD_Table Header Alignment.docx - Assigned to John as CP-ITI-1127
  • CP-ITI-mhd-note1-section-target-missing.docx - Assigned to John as CP-ITI-1128

These are deferred to a future call:

  • CP-ITI-AlternateUserId-in-ITI-18andITI-51.doc
  • CP-ITI-ESL_U=NotSpecialized.doc
  • CP-ITI-JB-ITI-homeCommunityId-audit-fix.doc
  • CP-ITI-NPFSm_Wrong_actor in message semantics.docx
  • CP-ITI-TP-fixXDFinconsistency.doc
  • CP-ITI-DENupdatesToOldVol3.docx

(3) Next in CPs

  • The ATNA CPs will go out in a ballot ASAP.
  • We will turn our attention back to regular CP processing. Some analysis is needed (Lynn) to determine a good focus.

May 31, 2018 - ATNA updates

Attendees: Bill Majurski (NIST), Elliott Lavy (N. Harris Computer), Ken Meyer (IBM Watson Health), Charles Parisot (GE Healthcare), Gregorio Canal & Mauro Zanardini (Arsenal.IT), Elliot Silver (Change Healthcare), Joe Lamy (Aegis/SSA), David Vaccaro (lifeIMAGE), Vassil Peytchev (Epic), Lynn Felhofer

(1) Prepare new ATNA Options for ballot ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance/CPs/1_Assigned/

-- CP-1124-04 - ATNA: Add Option: Non-Downgrading BCP195 TLS Secure Transport Connection (Charles)'

  • The CP contains two options -- Downgrading and Non-downgrading BCP195
  • Charles walked through the new edits:
    • adding the options to the Audit Consumer as well as ARR, SA and SN
    • new option-specific sections in Vol 1, including the use case/rationale for picking one option vs the other, and a description of the behavior required for each option
    • Vol 2 text for the non-downgrading option was reviewed last week; created new section for the downgrading option. We worked on eliminating text that just duplicated BCP195 rqmts and focus on IHE constraints specific to the options.
    • This CP is approved for ballot pending Lynn's editorial fixes

-- CPs for Ballot 48

(2) Next in CPs

  • We are moving to the 2018-19 cycle. The wiki & CP spreadsheet are updated accordingly. The new CP home page for ITI is http://wiki.ihe.net/index.php/ITI_Change_Proposals_2018-19
  • Ballot 48 with new ATNA options will go out on Monday June 4
  • Next week we will process the backlog of Incoming CPs

May 24, 2018 - ATNA updates

Attendees: Rob Horn (honorable guest SME), Manuel Metz (ASIP Sante), Joe Lamy (SSA/Aegis), Gregorio Canal (Arsenal.IT), Elliott Lavy (N. Harris Computer), Elliot Silver (Change HC), Dave Vaccaro (lifeIMAGE), Vassil Peytchev (Epic), Lynn Felhofer

(1) Assigned CPs ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance/CPs/1_Assigned

-- 1094 - ATNA: Add Option: Require server certificate domain name validation for all traffic over the public internet

-- 1124 - ATNA: Add Option: Non-Downgrading BCP195 TLS Secure Transport Connection

  • Discussion points:
    • packaging w/in the ATNA profile --
      • we decided to make two options in 1124: BCP and non-downgrading BCP -- enables individual profiles or deployments to require one or the other
      • ability to turn on/off these options at a deployment; need text w/in Vol 1 ATNA to explain this
      • because of the need to have two separate BCP195 options, we cannot combine all of these enhancements into one 'cyber' option. There can still be messaging associated w/ Connectathon packages these options together.
      • All options in 1094 and 1124 also apply to the Audit Consumer. Both CPs need to be updated to add the options to the Audit Consumer...this is an update to the "Add RESTful Query to ATNA" TI Supplement.
    • compatibility with legacy systems --
      • addressed by separating into two options and adding explanatory text about when to use these options
    • referencing BCP195 which is recommendation / current best practice
      • BCP195 will go through review/update using their normal process; IETF has historically been good at maintaining backward compatibility.
      • If we label the option with a date, it would 'freeze' the definition of this option to the published today
      • Toolkits will follow IETF revisions, reducing the risk of incompatibilities.
      • Thus we decided to remove reference to a specific version of BCP195. The Rationale of the CP will be updated to call this out as an item to comment on during CP Ballot.
    • Next steps for these CPs --
      • CP 1094 -- this CP is approved for Ballot pending Vassil's update to add this option to the Audit Consumer actor. There is no need for the committee to review of these updates prior to ballot.
      • CP 1124 -- this CP remains Assigned. The assignee is unclear. Lynn will send the CP as updated today to John and Charles. Edits needed: Finish updates to Vol 1, particularly addition of explanatory section. Add this option to the Audit Consumer. Review Vol 2a to see if splitting the option results in more text needed. See more detailed notes in version of -03 of this CP in the Assigned directory. If an updated version is ready in time, we will review it during next week's CP call.

(2) Close a few odds and ends from recent CP ballots

  • CP 709-06 from Ballot 47 - Accounting of Disclosures audit message
    • No votes were due to ASTM-2147 being 'withdrawn' status. Vassil confirmed that this ASTM E2147 was balloted for reinstatement in April 2018. Lynn will follow up via with those who commented on this CP.

(3) Next in CPs

  • Thurs May 31, 10-11am CDT -- If updates to CP 1124 are ready, we will review them. Else we will process the backlog of Incoming CPs.

May 10, 2018 - ATNA updates

Attendees: Ben Levy (Corepoint Health), Vassil Peytchev (Epic), Dave Vaccaro (lifeIMAGE), Elliot Silver (Change Healthcare), Elliott Lavy (N. Harris Computer), Gregorio Canal (Arsenal.IT), Neil Robinson (U.K.), Charles Parisot (GE Healthcare), Joe Lamy (SSA/Aegis), Lynn Felhofer

(1) Assigned CPs ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance/CPs/1_Assigned

  • 1094 - ATNA: Add Option: Require server certificate domain name validation for all traffic over the public internet --
    • This CP was discussed and refined. Some technical details related to the new option were moved to ITI-19 in Vol 2a.
    • Version 1094-04 is in the Assigned directory and contains updates from this call. It is expected to be reviewed and refined via email in the coming days.
    • Target is for final review on the May 24 call to approve it for Ballot
  • 1124 - ATNA: Add Option: Non-Downgrading BCP195 TLS Secure Transport Connection --
    • This CP was discussed and refined.
    • There was discussion about BCP195 containing *recommendations** that will change over time, introducing incompatibilities. So, the committees decided to refer to a specific version of the BCP (May 2015).
    • Version 1124-02 is in the Assigned directory and contains updates from this call. It is expected to be reviewed and refined via email in the coming days.
    • As with the prior CP, some details were moved to Vol 2a, but
  • As part of the upcoming review, it is likely that the changes in the two above CPs will be combined to represent one update to ATNA, probably as one combined option, but this is TBD. Input on this is welcome.

(2) Incoming CPs ftp://ftp.ihe.net/IT_Infrastructure/TF_Maintenance/CPs/0_Incoming/

  • discussion deferred

(3) Next in CPs

  • Tue May 15 - Ballot 47 comments due
  • Thu May 17 - Ballot 47 comment resolution (2 hour call 10am-noon CDT)
  • Thu May 24 - ATNA cyber update continued (2 hour call 10am-noon CDT)